The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Vell]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5130095&userid=138101&signature=DfwHWLbWjT8WSco2CIOGAA

Is this fair?

I'd say unfair to the Pets on the top.

[emjayy]

Blackiie - Both the Dec 18th pups are v. rares, so you will gain a v. rare and two others in exchange for a v. rare. I would do it, but it's up to how much you like the dog pups.

The Green Sorbet is the rarest sorbet and has almost equall rarity to the purple toxic, which is worth more than the blue toxic. You have to think about the month they were born in and not just their rarity. The jewel sundog is very rare and so is the blue toxic, but there is no hope that you would get a jewel sundog for a blue tox. Understand what I'm saying?

EDIT: Hello Vell

[izzi]

is this fair?

me: moonswirl
them: coontail + sorbet or possibly July PPS + something

i dont know whether thats fair, and i wouldn't know what to put with the coontail to make it fair otherwise..?
any ideas?

Thanks x x x

[PickledBudgie]

Okay I know I'm a noob but is this a fair trade

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a2_BD0m5nw

[Bluish]

is this fair?

me: moonswirl
them: coontail + sorbet or possibly July PPS + something

i dont know whether thats fair, and i wouldn't know what to put with the coontail to make it fair otherwise..?
any ideas?

Thanks x x x

It depends what the 'something' is at the end @_@

[emjayy]

is this fair?

me: moonswirl
them: coontail + sorbet or possibly July PPS + something

i dont know whether thats fair, and i wouldn't know what to put with the coontail to make it fair otherwise..?
any ideas?

Thanks x x x

Whats the something? Coontail + July PPS is overpaying for the moonswirl.

[izzi]

is this fair?

me: moonswirl
them: coontail + sorbet or possibly July PPS + something

i dont know whether thats fair, and i wouldn't know what to put with the coontail to make it fair otherwise..?
any ideas?

Thanks x x x

It depends what the 'something' is at the end @_@

well thats what i dont know >.< a common august or september?

[izzi]

is this fair?

me: moonswirl
them: coontail + sorbet or possibly July PPS + something

i dont know whether thats fair, and i wouldn't know what to put with the coontail to make it fair otherwise..?
any ideas?

Thanks x x x

Whats the something? Coontail + July PPS is overpaying for the moonswirl.

thanks blackiie <3
i'd rather have trade for the coontail, and no its coontail, OR july pps plus something x

[emjayy]

is this fair?

me: moonswirl
them: coontail + sorbet or possibly July PPS + something

i dont know whether thats fair, and i wouldn't know what to put with the coontail to make it fair otherwise..?
any ideas?

Thanks x x x

Whats the something? Coontail + July PPS is overpaying for the moonswirl.

thanks blackiie <3
i'd rather have trade for the coontail so thanks x x x

Welcome C: <3

[saint.EXE]

Okay I know I'm a noob but is this a fair trade

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a2_BD0m5nw

Well, I don't know... I guess if you don't like horses, yes, It's unfair but it depends on your like factor