The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[snowflake139]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5106978&userid=788&signature=LUpbngkkiBtQEsxYDIzKBQ
How unfair for UR Malk? (In other words, what should I add?)

Thanks in advance!

I've read (on this thread) that the UR Malk goes for as much as a common August '08, such as the Pink Balloon Dog. I believe that you need to add a few VR Septembers to your side or pets equivalent to that value, though determining what can be added to a trade isn't one of my specialties.

Thanks!

[average]

I think unfair to UR Malk, but I just wanna' be sure.

Thanks Radical-Edward. ^_^ Other opinions? I'm stuck in between a tie.

I'd say unfair to them.

GUYS NEW TRADE SUPER URGENT HELP!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ncj5LHm_ow ??????

How unfair to them??/

[That Flute Girl]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5109711&userid=39760&signature=r5mNPrp6EB4MPZXx5SIdEw
Add a sunjewel bunny on my side.

Fair or not? urgent!

I think it's unfair to you-seeing as the Green Sorbet is worth a lot(rarest Sorbet) but you might want another opinion.

[BieberFever101x]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5109711&userid=39760&signature=r5mNPrp6EB4MPZXx5SIdEw
Add a sunjewel bunny on my side.

Fair or not? urgent!

I would say this is a bit unfair to the bottom but it looks ok?

[BieberFever101x]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5109711&userid=39760&signature=r5mNPrp6EB4MPZXx5SIdEw
Add a sunjewel bunny on my side.

Fair or not? urgent!

I think it's unfair to you-seeing as the Green Sorbet is worth a lot(rarest Sorbet) but you might want another opinion.

I second

[luupine]

Please answer soon, so as not to keep my partner waiting; http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g5RDzG6yYg

(: Fair? Or unfair?

[kivr & fireflii]

I think unfair to UR Malk, but I just wanna' be sure. Other opinions? I'm stuck in between a tie.

Thanks Galaxy. :3

[Rynn Zekio Zusha]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5109652&userid=69896&signature=qfkJDVK64w1Ene7GO2b52g

I'm really popular tonight, lol.. ^_^

Anyways, anyone?

very unfair to them, nobody wants the rainbow draft and a few uncommons wouldnt make it any fairer

Okay, they originally sent it with the rainbow draft and 3 dogs.. one that wasn't in my trades.. but I sent that suggestion to them, I'll see how they send it back and add some pets, and I happen to like the rainbow drafts. They may be common rares, but they are worth something.

[Animall]

Thanks! Other opinions would be appreciated^^

[ki-neko animura]

White grown July 08 for coontail