The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pikachu]

OFFER 1
OR
OFFER 2

K out of these two. Which is the better offer? Or are they about equal? (Again, the Moon Pup in OFFER 1 is a Dog Tag Moon)

1st offer is better.

[Dee & Faulk]

OFFER 1
OR
OFFER 2

K out of these two. Which is the better offer? Or are they about equal? (Again, the Moon Pup in OFFER 1 is a Dog Tag Moon)

Dogtag moon offer definitely. You rarely get this much for zebras these days.

['Possum]

UR malk dog and newborn rose dog(outcome unknown)

for

CE Galaxy?

Probably fair. The Rose Dog has to be the Red or PPS. I'd wait till tomorrow and see for sure if it grows at 12 days or not before I traded. If not it's a gamble. There's a huge difference in the rarity of the two.

[decalcomanie]

Okay, last question about this xD:
UR B-wolf for full set of Tribals (including Bunny, Cat is not needed), Blue and Red Toxic and Non-Swirl/Non-Coon?

[xChry.]

UR malk dog and newborn rose dog(outcome unknown)

for

CE Galaxy?

I would say a little unfair to the Ceg.

[NaziZombiez]

What does a NonSwirl have to add to be fair to a MoonSwirl?

[xChry.]

Green Sorbet Blue Sorbet and an 08 fox cat
for
a Non-Tag

[Sorrel]

Okay, last question about this xD:
UR B-wolf for full set of Tribals (including Bunny, Cat is not needed), Blue and Red Toxic and Non-Swirl/Non-Coon?

Honestly? Since the rarities of every pet has gone down (including the UR B-wolf), I'd have to say that the full set of tribals and all of that is worth taking if the b-wolf is yours.

[devm]

UR malk dog and newborn rose dog(outcome unknown)

for

CE Galaxy?

Probably fair. The Rose Dog has to be the Red or PPS. I'd wait till tomorrow and see for sure if it grows at 12 days or not before I traded. If not it's a gamble. There's a huge difference in the rarity of the two.

well it's 9 days old right now so it still has a chance to be blue(i'll probably see by tonight) but if it turned out to be a blue one would it be fair?

[Sorrel]

So, which would be better?:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0r7EcizYRA

or

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xMgEiSUJCw

Mine is the Blue Balloon and I'm really wondering which one is better to accept...

And

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NCwWnuIyaQ + a blue balloon pup on the side with the angel advent