The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Elwynie]

Which offer is fair or the best? :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... t1D80ItTow
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... id=5051226

Thank you!~

Can't see the secnond one, but the first looks good

Here was the second one.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oXXsEK0T9Q

[-Ash's-Outlaw-]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5057676&userid=103315&signature=TUwvfOD2dTdiwwn2tHJ8OA

I gave her a sun dog for somthing she said was very rare. it is rare and I WANT MY SUN DOG BACK



IS IT FAIR TO DO THIS?

Unfortunately, you accepted the trade. That makes it pretty final. I'm afraid this is just a hard lesson learned. Check your rarities. If you'd have come on here and asked about the trade before accepting it that would be different. Fair or not, you accepted it.

No, she sent a trade for it, then I said lets wait until they grow, then she accepted it without telling me she did it. So i didnt want that pet, and she took the other from me without me knowing...She sent a trade, i edited saying wait till they grow, she accepted the TRADE, then took a very rare from me without me wanting to trade


IT WAS MARIGOLD AND THANK YOU THANK YOU

[-Ash's-Outlaw-]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5057676&userid=103315&signature=TUwvfOD2dTdiwwn2tHJ8OA

I gave her a sun dog for somthing she said was very rare. it is rare and I WANT MY SUN DOG BACK



IS IT FAIR TO DO THIS?

Unfortunately, you accepted the trade. That makes it pretty final. I'm afraid this is just a hard lesson learned. Check your rarities. If you'd have come on here and asked about the trade before accepting it that would be different. Fair or not, you accepted it.

[LayVander]

Which offer is fair or the best? :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... t1D80ItTow
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... id=5051226

Thank you!~

Personally to me that looks unfair to them. I have that puppy and its only rare. (judging on the first one because the second one can't be seen)

[Sorrel]

@georgelilly, who was it? I might be able to get it back for you.

Hi, umm...is a sundog worth a CE Galaxy? I am going to trade my galaxy, and I don't want to trade it for something of lesser value...

Any of the Sun Dogs is worth more than a CE Galaxy. That's a cheaper July '08

Ok, so I'll add. Thanks! ^^

[pikachu]

Which offer is fair or the best? :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... t1D80ItTow
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... id=5051226

Thank you!~

First looks better. :3

[Julia]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5058854&userid=4163&signature=6nMv5kRlRqj5qw583szrzg
I'm not really a fan of these dogs but yea. Should I accept?

[-Ash's-Outlaw-]

@georgelilly, who was it? I might be able to get it back for you.

Hi, umm...is a sundog worth a CE Galaxy? I am going to trade my galaxy, and I don't want to trade it for something of lesser value...

Any of the Sun Dogs is worth more than a CE Galaxy. That's a cheaper July '08

Ok, so I'll add. Thanks! ^^

IF YOU COULD GET IT BACK I WOULD GIVE YOU TWO RARES, AND WLs

['Possum]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5057676&userid=103315&signature=TUwvfOD2dTdiwwn2tHJ8OA

I gave her a sun dog for somthing she said was very rare. it is rare and I WANT MY SUN DOG BACK



IS IT FAIR TO DO THIS?

Unfortunately, you accepted the trade. That makes it pretty final. I'm afraid this is just a hard lesson learned. Check your rarities. If you'd have come on here and asked about the trade before accepting it that would be different. Fair or not, you accepted it.

No, she sent a trade for it, then I said lets wait until they grow, then she accepted it without telling me she did it. So i didnt want that pet, and she took the other from me without me knowing...She sent a trade, i edited saying wait till they grow, she accepted the TRADE, then took a very rare from me without me wanting to trade


IT WAS MARIGOLD AND THANK YOU THANK YOU

Well then if that's the case, that's a totally different story. You accidentally sent the trade back as a TRADE instead of a SUGGESTION or CANCEL. You can contact Nick about it. Explain to him what happened. In your message you've clearly stated that you did NOT intend to trade the pet. He'll be able to get it back to you. Just send him a PM. Good luck and let us know how it turns out. (This does belong in the trade rant thread BTW but let us know anyway ^_^)

[Zephayer]

click
(moonpup is a dogtag)