The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Scripted]

I need help deciding whose bid is the best. They are bidding on my white July pup.
DayDreamer- CE Galaxy pup+VR Dogtag Bunny+ 1 Pocky+08 blue & orange dog+Target Dog+08 Grey Advent+Music Player+Skull Bandana
MinnesotaMommy- CE Galaxy
Anonymous Bidder(real player, not a joke)- CE Galaxy pup+VR Pink 08 rerelease+08 blue & orange bobtail+180 C$
Dawny- BMD+Red Rose+VR Bunny+08 Advent pup+Malk Foal+Snow PPS(Blue)+Liver Aussie PPS+500 C$

Personally, I think that daydreamer has the best offer, but you should always get a 2nd opinion.

Side Note: it looks like you're going to get your Dreamie, huh? Congrats!

[brian emo]

This is for my non-balloon auction. Please refer to the attachment. I believe it's not fair for my non-balloon, but I'm just making sure.

You'd be so very right to think that- that's an August 08 VR, and the rarest of the 3 balloon dogs. :3

[Candle.Jack]

This is for my non-balloon auction. Please refer to the attachment. I believe it's not fair for my non-balloon, but I'm just making sure.

You'd be so very right to think that- that's an August 08 VR, and the rarest of the 3 balloon dogs. :3

Thank you. :3 It's really tough to get a good idea on how rare this dog is. x_x Thanks much.

[koth]

UR mint horse for sunback or white july?

[brian emo]

I still have an unanswered question- would something need to be added to make this trade fair?
Joker -for- Yellow Sorbet?

[Akami-chan]

pink sorbet for blue sorbet?

I think that is slightly unfair to the Pink Sorbet, but I'm not 100% sure ;]

Should be slightly unfair to the Blue Sorbet, although not by much at all. All 4 Sorbets are bunched up together on the Updated Rares List. Although I think there's more demand for the Blue..

I also thought it was blue that was more rare XD
Green, Blue, Yellow, Pink?
Or maybe Yellow = Pink?

[Niko]

I still have an unanswered question- would something need to be added to make this trade fair?
Joker -for- Yellow Sorbet?

If the person with the joker accepts it its a great deal. But if they want more, I suggest a rare or an 08 uncommon

[Candle.Jack]

I got another bid for my non-balloon. They are bidding a UR apple. I can't really decide if that's on par with a fair trade since I thought the apple was an '09 release. I may need a few opinions.

[Allizia]

I got another bid for my non-balloon. They are bidding a UR apple. I can't really decide if that's on par with a fair trade since I thought the apple was an '09 release. I may need a few opinions.

i clicked the egg thing in your sig and it changed xD

On topic, what needs to be added to the galaxy to be fair for a mountain zebra?

[Candle.Jack]

I got another bid for my non-balloon. They are bidding a UR apple. I can't really decide if that's on par with a fair trade since I thought the apple was an '09 release. I may need a few opinions.

i clicked the egg thing in your sig and it changed xD

*Whispers* Thanks. =D