The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Allizia]

pink sorbet for blue sorbet?

I think that is slightly unfair to the Pink Sorbet, but I'm not 100% sure ;]

Thanks ^^ Another opinion?

[pikachu]

pink sorbet for blue sorbet?

If i remember correctly, Pink is more rare.

[Niko]

I need help deciding whose bid is the best. They are bidding on my white July pup.
DayDreamer- CE Galaxy pup+VR Dogtag Bunny+ 1 Pocky+08 blue & orange dog+Target Dog+08 Grey Advent+Music Player+Skull Bandana
MinnesotaMommy- CE Galaxy
Anonymous Bidder(real player, not a joke)- CE Galaxy pup+VR Pink 08 rerelease+08 blue & orange bobtail+180 C$
Dawny- BMD+Red Rose+VR Bunny+08 Advent pup+Malk Foal+Snow PPS(Blue)+Liver Aussie PPS+500 C$

[koth]

pink sorbet for blue sorbet?

No, I think the blue sorbet is rarer, I suggest the person offering the pink sorbet adding a '08 rare (I'm not sure)

[Allizia]

pink sorbet for blue sorbet?

No, I think the blue sorbet is rarer, I suggest the person offering the pink sorbet adding a '08 rare (I'm not sure)

Now im confused xD

[Scripted]

pink sorbet for blue sorbet?

I think that is slightly unfair to the Pink Sorbet, but I'm not 100% sure ;]

Should be slightly unfair to the Blue Sorbet, although not by much at all. All 4 Sorbets are bunched up together on the Updated Rares List. Although I think there's more demand for the Blue..

[Coleslaw]

pink sorbet for blue sorbet?

No, I think the blue sorbet is rarer, I suggest the person offering the pink sorbet adding a '08 rare (I'm not sure)

I second this, the Blue Sorbet is the second rarest of the sorbets.

[Candle.Jack]

This is for my non-balloon auction. Please refer to the attachment. I believe it's not fair for my non-balloon, but I'm just making sure.

[Dennie]

Are the pink and blue balloon dogs equal in value?

yup. the non-balloon is worth a little more.

Really? but it's so boring... lol

[koth]

Both for sunback? Need urgently. D:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LjHYIAxeXw


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nBOpq4JICg

Are they both the same person offering? If it is then the top one is fairer