The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Dennie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5050041
For the white punk store dog? Fair?

you have to post the link from the "share this trade" button, or we can't see it

Woops!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... V3HpmJIjMw

I am pretty sure most people in this thread would call that unfair for you because most people don't like trading dog rares for anything but dog rares but.... I think it's really up to you. Depends on how much you love your store dog.

[That Flute Girl]

UR Malk Dog and Rose Puppy(Unknown Outcome)
for
CE Galaxy?
Need an answer as soon as possible-Thanks!!!

[Niko]

I need help deciding whose bid is the best. They are bidding on my white July pup.
DayDreamer- CE Galaxy pup+VR Dogtag Bunny+ 1 Pocky+08 blue & orange dog+Target Dog+08 Grey Advent+Music Player+Skull Bandana
MinnesotaMommy- CE Galaxy
Anonymous Bidder(real player, not a joke)- CE Galaxy pup+VR Pink 08 rerelease+08 blue & orange bobtail+180 C$
Dawny- BMD+Red Rose+VR Bunny+08 Advent pup+Malk Foal+Snow PPS(Blue)+Liver Aussie PPS+500 C$

[hakemie]

Erm,english please?

[brian emo]

What could be added to this to make it fair?
Joker [true date]
for
Yellow sorbet [re-release]?

[koth]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kUCiCx_wjA
If it isn't then what needs to be added to the side that isn't fair?
Thanks

[hakemie]

What could be added to this to make it fair?
Joker [true date]
for
Yellow sorbet [re-release]?

I guess you should add an Uncommon '08 to the Joker side,get another opinion.

[Niko]

What could be added to this to make it fair?
Joker [true date]
for
Yellow sorbet [re-release]?

I guess you should add an Uncommon '08 to the Joker side,get another opinion.

Maybe add a rare or an 08 uncommon to the sorbet side?

[hakemie]

I'm still pretty much a n00b at rarities,but I'm getting there :3

[Rachel Amber]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LrTGkurpTA