The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[sinpai]

Need help please
can anyone tell me if this is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73834121&userid=915619&signature=2GEqBeDtGFY7NgPQDjmfyg
Thank you

unfair to you, their pet is worth only 30-35 c$

Given that a 2015 store pet is worth a late 2009 rare, which is worth 40C$ or more, it's a fair trade. From that perspective at least.
.

The C$ guide says 30-35 even for late 09 rares, only mid & early 09 rares are worth 40 C$ so still unfair to the C$ side, please do not correct me with false statements

[cleodora soleil <3]

is this fair?
i really want those two tree dogs

[The Plague.]

is this fair?
i really want those two tree dogs

They'd need to add another 2018 rare. 2 rares of 1 year = a rare of the last year

[cleodora soleil <3]

is this fair?
i really want those two tree dogs

They'd need to add another 2018 rare. 2 rares of 1 year = a rare of the last year

thanks!

[Dang It Moon Moon!]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73834120&userid=797249&signature=DF9ks5EqbSP-ZZLmPsrdkw
Would this be fair to my store pets?



What about this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73836237&userid=797249&signature=9QZnzS36JCTwCgjZNUEu-A

[Mapleface]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73836224
i have no idea XD

[N64]

Heya how Is This for my sorbet? Tysm For Any Help!

[s a g e]

which bid is better ?

Coontail = 130 fairy goats
or
Joker + sorbet = 130 fairy goats

[Chocolate_Chip]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73827906&userid=907615&signature=xpnAHrfWRMPpG0ci4sKJLQ


Would this be fair need help thank you!

[the]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73834120&userid=797249&signature=DF9ks5EqbSP-ZZLmPsrdkw
Would this be fair to my store pets?



What about this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73836237&userid=797249&signature=9QZnzS36JCTwCgjZNUEu-A

First trade is unfair to you. Your side is worth 5 rares '09 and their side is adding up to roughly 3-3.5.
In the second trade they're technically overpaying, as the cocoon pps is worth 6-7 rares '09 and your side is worth 4. Some of your pets may fetch overpay though, so it seems pretty fair demand wise.