The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[sinpai]

What could I add to their side to make it fair if possible? I looked through their groups but I'm not sure the value of their pets v mine

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811388&userid=825141&signature=LP2p1V_Qa-Sb7isLGD83RQ

The '17 store pet griffin = mid '10 rare and the '18 store pet dragon = late '10 rare
so your side = 2 later '10 rares or 1 late 09 rare (using the 2:1 system)

Are these fair? (making sure before doing anything)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73801849&userid=772304&signature=JgprqGHtOYdZ7WovOH4y8A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73801843&userid=772304&signature=MN0ZXlmjR-mpTV2xj8zuNg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73801830&userid=772304&signature=dMGdDRUD6VaVe7uI9aMgYw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73801824&userid=772304&signature=zVeUOKqeoB_VOfk_MlYxmg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73802099&userid=772304&signature=gm9C4QYqrS9hOGMOfnYLew
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73801996&userid=772304&signature=AtViYqdXBdSOz5CYodLjtA

Id like to know if any of these are fair too I'm 1 of the trades

Trade 1: Unfair to you, 2014 store pets = 35-40 C$
Trade 2: Unfair by the 3 month rule, the white dog is a 09 Jan while the christmas light dog is a dec 09
Trade 3: Hollyfox = 7-8 mixed 09 rares
their side = 5' 09 R + 1 '13 R + 1'13 UC + 1 '15 R ( the C$) So unfair to the hollyfox
Trade 4: Each '14 store pet = 35-40 C$, so unfair to them by 5 C$ but I personally wouldn't accept due to C$ needing some time to trade off sometimes but up to you what you would prefer to have/keep, C$ can be easy if you find the right person
Trade 5: Fair swap, but the Hollyfox can have some demand
Trade 6: Hollyfox = 7-8 mixed 09 R
Their side = 5 09 R
so unfair to holly fox

[then]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811303&userid=938744&signature=iaP9LGs0fvH9jkGC_2X5cg


trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811389&userid=938744&signature=s8Hb4XcQDWQwafLTDYer9w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811801&userid=938744&signature=A1sIQQDO6_b3th5k7oxxoQ

This is for my auction, but which trade is most fair?

[Ruiying]

xx

is this fair??

thanks for all and any help!

If I'm not mistaken, the quantity side adds up to 195 2009 rares + 1 2012 rare + 1 2016 rare. Quick note though, I counted some pets as '09 rares (like the zodiacs and uncommon Warriors) since that's what they're going for. It's also possible that I miscounted, so I'd say to have an error margin of ± 10 for the '09 rares number.
As I've mentioned in a previous post, I read somewhere that the Scarf PPS is worth 22 '09 rares and the Skeleton PPS is worth 75-97 '09 rares. I don't have an exact value for the UR Butterbun, but the green toxic (two tiers below it on the mainlist) is valued between 264-338 '09 rares.
All this being said, I'm not taking into account the demand for a huge quantity trade down like this. In my opinion, I'd trade just the UR Butterbun for their bulk. It doesn't have the best demand but this might make up for the gap between the rares and its worth, depending on both what it's currently going for and how you value it personally. Like I said, I'm not completely sure what it's worth, but it's highly uncommon to find someone who'll trade that many rares for a mainlist.

[Laelia]

Can I have some advice on this trade please?

The black advent is worth 1-2 sorbets demand-wise. Liontails go for around a sorbet with demand. So if you value the black advent at 2 sorbets, the trade would be unfair by roughly a sorbet (since the other rares obviously do not add up to the worth of a sorbet). If you value the black advent at 1 sorbet, then you would be overpaying with the rest of the rares. Keep in mind this is all demand-wise.

[then]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811303&userid=938744&signature=iaP9LGs0fvH9jkGC_2X5cg


trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811389&userid=938744&signature=s8Hb4XcQDWQwafLTDYer9w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811801&userid=938744&signature=A1sIQQDO6_b3th5k7oxxoQ

This is for my auction, but which trade is most fair?

[myth;]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811303&userid=938744&signature=iaP9LGs0fvH9jkGC_2X5cg


trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811389&userid=938744&signature=s8Hb4XcQDWQwafLTDYer9w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811801&userid=938744&signature=A1sIQQDO6_b3th5k7oxxoQ

This is for my auction, but which trade is most fair?

None of them are fair, the shima is a 2009 rare, they're all overpaying.

The second trade is worth the most.

[then]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811303&userid=938744&signature=iaP9LGs0fvH9jkGC_2X5cg


trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811389&userid=938744&signature=s8Hb4XcQDWQwafLTDYer9w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73811801&userid=938744&signature=A1sIQQDO6_b3th5k7oxxoQ

This is for my auction, but which trade is most fair?

None of them are fair, the shima is a 2009 rare, they're all overpaying.

The second trade is worth the most.

Ok
But with demand?

[Ruiying]

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added to either side? Thanks!

[444cupid]

is this a fair trade? thank you so much!

[PinkSugar]

Is this fair?

A HUGE thanks for any help! ❤