The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Lunameyza]

I'm really bad with items, so is this fair? Thanks for any opinions!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73728034&userid=148610&signature=uYRDevQPQAup2iPyaR6xNg

[myth;]

is this fair?
I value my mall at 1 non and my goal at 1 non if that helps!
Would it be easy to trade down their side?

The malk can trade for a non, the foal is only worth about 2 sorbets however, and has no demand to prove otherwise. Overall, your side is worth about 3.5 nons, so it's unfair to the moonswirl.

[Animall]

Help! Please! Would it be fair for just the GWJ and one of the others?

and this bid?

I probably should not be answering this buuut this seems fair because the flowerpot is a tier higher than the GWJ and those pets fill up the gap. The flower has higher demand

Another opinion? (she/he is my trading partner x.x)

I traded away my flowerpot for a gwj alone. The flower doesn’t have the greatest demand, neither does the gwj. Both go for 1-2 sorbets.

In my personal opinion, I wouldn’t take it. Dogs have higher demand in general, and I don’t feel like it’s worth adding the quantity on your side. I personally had a really hard time trading off my flower.

[partly cloudy]

is this fair? (i think my side would be overpay)

[Vylad]

is this fair? (i think my side would be overpay)

For sure overpay on your side. The zodiac dogs are only worth an '09 rare with demand.

I'd get another opinion though .

[partly cloudy]

is this fair? (i think my side would be overpay)

For sure overpay on your side. The zodiac dogs are only worth an '09 rare with demand.

I'd get another opinion though .

thank youu!

[Animall]

is this fair? (i think my side would be overpay)

For sure overpay on your side. The zodiac dogs are only worth an '09 rare with demand.

I'd get another opinion though :).

thank youu!

I agree, a ridiculous amount of overpay on your side. I would never pay more than one 09 rare for a zodiac dog. Your aussie can go for overpay alone, and he’s already worth 2 09 rares. ^^

[. faded .]

i dont know if this is okay

[partly cloudy]

i just got another one

again, im sure this may not be fair since my side is valued a late '10 rare (i think) and theirs (i think) doesn't value that since they are event pets? please correct me im still learning

[. faded .]

i just got another one

again, im sure this may not be fair since my side is valued a late '10 rare (i think) and theirs (i think) doesn't value that since they are event pets? please correct me im still learning

im pretty sure your side does value an late '10 rare, which the tiger store pet is worth a late '10 rare. so it may be fair please get a second opinion