The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

Is this a fair trade???

And This?

The second trade is very unfair to them.
Their pet is a Noncoon, above gap mainlist.
Worth 252 Mid Advents. (mind you, not something you'd have to offer but, given you're offering a mid advent, this is for example purposes)
Your pet is only a Tier 7 Advent, so, 1 Mid Advent worth.
You'd need to add a lot to your side for it to be fair to them.

Okay, what about the first trade??

Edit:
Help please?

[kxLJM]

i never know what older store pets are worth, any help is greatly appreciated, thank you in advance! aaa

[M4NICWOLF]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73322622&userid=786950&signature=cJoMTDLkeFWJgDN8RcqnHg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73322696&userid=786950&signature=1mza_GmgbIfJ631lxz03Og

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73322621&userid=786950&signature=QoGgvmTEIWsuN1kbdPAojA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73322956&userid=786950&signature=TLcxnNk9TtMsCEAKtYj-HA


I dont know which trade to accept! im dying

[popping star]

i never know what older store pets are worth, any help is greatly appreciated, thank you in advance! aaa

As the store pet was released in 2011, it's worth 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare.
Therefore, the trade is unfair to you.

[Smokey.Wolf]

fair? What would I have to add if it isn't?

[skelliursa]

xxx
Could I get some help with this trade ?
I'm really interested in the Wolf PPS but not sure what my side is worth.
Thanks for any help. =)

[Horror]

xxx
Could I get some help with this trade ?
I'm really interested in the Wolf PPS but not sure what my side is worth.
Thanks for any help. =)

Your side is worth a gray dragon so it's unfair to them by a low sept

fair? What would I have to add if it isn't?

Rarity wise it's huge overpay as raven's are worth extremely little
Demand is just up to you and your partner on how you value it

[⁕ꕤ MisuCats ꕤ⁕]

- I really need help with these two trade ;; v ;;) which one is fairer ??

1) trades/viewtrade.php?id=73319412&userid=809142&signature=gdNQJ9fPzZ0dRpI2k3KhtA

2) trades/viewtrade.php?id=73319581&userid=809142&signature=U3AONhYJSrmt7j56lO8ziA

Thank for any help ;;;; w ;;;)

opinion 1:
They're both pretty fair.
The grey mini husky is worth 5-6 '09 rares.
The first trade is worth roughly 5 '09 rares + a '10 rare.
The second is worth 5 '09 rares. (I'm unsure of the worth of the items, sorry!)



thank u !!

second opinion ? C:

[soulsilver]

urgent, please help
is this fair? opinions? trades/viewtrade.php?id=73317888&userid=657583&signature=1dBFEa_7xCkU0pD2OFoOjg thank you!! ignore the items, they're free extras

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

HELP PLEASE!
I really need help, thank you!
Warning: Bulk trade!

Edit: Would a roadkill be better then a Shima Longtail?