The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Macklin584]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73267817&userid=754287&signature=BIcTJHm-pHaZb0I1sbwbDw
is this fair?

it's an overpay by ur side since the '17 store pets are worth a mid '10 rare each.

[MoonWolf90]

How’s this? How can they make it fair?
also this please?

the tope on is unfair beucase picky never have good demand and blue rose have good demand

[the]

How’s this? How can they make it fair?
also this please?

First trade: Their side is worth 4 mid advents + roughly 5 rares '09, so they shoud add 2 mid advents/red dragon + 1-3 rares '09 or light leopard/target dog.

Second trade: The WWA is worth 21 mid advents and your side is worth 10/red x pps, so unfair to them.

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

Help! asap would be wonderful! Thank you.

the banana usually goes for around an non, so they are technically overpaying.
it just depends if you have the patience to trade the banana. i personally would stick with the ur foal (+add), simply because it's easier to trade.

I agree that they are overpaying, though I had some issues with the UR Foal in the past in trading it fairly, so really it's up to you which you prefer.[/quote]
Okay! I will think about it!

Edit: Would it still be fair if I took out the cake dog? Also this?

[Macklin584]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73267779&userid=924297&signature=05b5UlWM5dCEqFAqYLah7A
can someone rate this bid (its a different one) 1-10?

[mountain tree]

hello, I am interested in many of this user's pets, but I'm not sure what would be fair to ask for my '08 VR pup.
any help/opinions would be appreciated! [link]

also, what do people think about this swap?

[KikisDelivery97]

UR fox for the 3 liontail store pets? Thanks in advance!

Also this??

[MoonWolf90]

fair? need asap answer please
boop

[polyphon]

would this be a good trade to take?
i'm not too sure what the sunback goes for right now so any help would be much appreciated <3

[the]

id=73242600&userid=752234&signature=jdfmkCUVKdtCEQALmldsMw]Help![/url] asap would be wonderful! Thank you.

the banana usually goes for around an non, so they are technically overpaying.
it just depends if you have the patience to trade the banana. i personally would stick with the ur foal (+add), simply because it's easier to trade.
I agree that they are overpaying, though I had some issues with the UR Foal in the past in trading it fairly, so really it's up to you which you prefer.

Okay! I will think about it!

Edit: Would it still be fair if I took out the cake dog? Also this?

At the moment they're already overpaying. If you remove the cake dog this trade will be more unfair to them.
Second trade is unfair to you, their side doesn't even add up to a sorbet.