The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Clawdina]

Hey can I get an opinion on this trade? Thanks! trades/viewtrade.php?id=73263606&userid=158024&signature=Y3MhAJKPoazjX7IcSJP1dQ

rarity wise, it's fair, but sitting cats can often go for a bit of overpay

[yaksha]

IS THis fair and would you accept considering the demand of all pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73260661&userid=720831&signature=oD12gQ22MAKsOmDzy30ncA

Personally I would take that, I value the liontail at a sorb at most and the other pets don't make much of a difference, and the Phoenix is worth a non + sorb. Though if you happen to value your pets differently then this may be different

Thank you, could I get second opinion c:?

[Clawdina]

IS THis fair and would you accept considering the demand of all pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73260661&userid=720831&signature=oD12gQ22MAKsOmDzy30ncA

Personally I would take that, I value the liontail at a sorb at most and the other pets don't make much of a difference, and the Phoenix is worth a non + sorb. Though if you happen to value your pets differently then this may be different

Thank you, could I get second opinion c:?

[HiddenVocals]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73263995&userid=814498&signature=v_k5wU6NiLDiVVeZk1jsVw

Is this fair? Tysm!

[dear.chaton]

Uh what about this?

[Taaree]

Is this fair?

And which one is better?:
1
2

[omnos5]

Is this fair? If not, what should them or me add?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=73263975&userid=111350&signature=vim0AHC-m1bOswGYO9RZlA

Thanks!

[ginseng,]

Is this a fair trade?

[Ichiban Kasuga]

Is this a fair trade?

Unfair to the Malk Elemental, as it is a 2009 rare, and the store pet is only worth around a mid 2010 rare

[WisteriaDragon]

How is this?