The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[UniqueTrash]

Fair?
How is this bid for my malk?
(

[Clawdina]

Fair?
How is this bid for my malk?
(

Well, pickles tend to go for a non when demand is factored in and so does the malk, so I'd say that's a fair bid by most standards, but it mostly depends on where you value each side

is this trade fair for shima longtail?

strictly rarity wise, unfair to you
demand-wise, it most often goes for low-mid advents, and your side adds up to about a 1st-2nd tier advent so it all depends on where you and your trading partner value the shima

[astraf]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73256743&userid=661008&signature=nYlpy4Lpx9h2jn76GAIjow
Fair?

[HACKSAW]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73257650&userid=649208&signature=sZI56K7rJ_cDnhVrTrF0Gg
this?

[Clawdina]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73256743&userid=661008&signature=nYlpy4Lpx9h2jn76GAIjow
Fair?

I would say unfair to them. The speech bubble is a free item in the C$ store, and the mug was a free item in the 2014 advent calendar so I doubt that those two items equal the value of the rare. I would get a second opinion too c:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73257650&userid=649208&signature=sZI56K7rJ_cDnhVrTrF0Gg
this?

yay math
I would say unfair to you. All the rares except the 2015 rares add up to about a 2008 rare and the 2015 rares equal about a 2011 rare and 2013 rare, so I believe that their side only adds up to about 2 of your dogs

[mothcat]

How about this trade?

Thanks all of you beautiful people, have a spectacular day/night!~ <3

[Clawdina]

How about this trade?

Thanks all of you beautiful people, have a spectacular day/night!~ <3

unfair to you since the store pet it worth about a late 2009 or early 2010 rare

[-TempleOfMadness-]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73262964&userid=616481&signature=R-ozM30LoR2YWHA_ilkA-A

Hey, is this fair?

[MoonWolf90]

this a non and the german shaepard dog set worth a ur holly

[heartfades]

Hey can I get an opinion on this trade? Thanks! trades/viewtrade.php?id=73263606&userid=158024&signature=Y3MhAJKPoazjX7IcSJP1dQ