The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Horror]

How about this one?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73246984&userid=612819&signature=AZY-IYTf54JbleLZJ2XECg

Unfair to them by roughly around a red x PPS, your side is only worth a mid sept list
Demand is just up to you on how you feel about trading up and how low or high you value the apple

[SylverTears]

How about this one?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73246984&userid=612819&signature=AZY-IYTf54JbleLZJ2XECg

Unfair to them by roughly around a red x PPS, your side is only worth a mid sept list
Demand is just up to you on how you feel about trading up and how low or high you value the apple

Thank you! If someone could PM me advice on how to climb higher up on the rare's list let me know x.x

[peachy_froyo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73247100&userid=931550&signature=DRKfnBULAvT_gzmWbaatoA
:7

[z i m]

clicky <3
should I do this? I know this is more than fair, but how easy is it to get fair trades for the dogtag? I've had trouble with them in the past, so I don't know that they're worth the trouble unless it's gotten better in the past few months.

just got another;;
this?

if you are looking to trade down the dogtag, you probably won't get it's full worth.
3 nons is usually the highest the set goes for, but i personally wouldn't go for an dogtag for them.

thanks! what about the moonswirl?

[still]

Is this a fair trade?

Fair. Your cat is worth another 09 rare although the elemental cats do have good demand and commonly go for overpay. Malk cats may also go for slight overpay, although it depends upon the user. However, you'll have to decide how much you value the elemental cat's demand at c:

[mothcat]

Here's a happy trade

I don't think it's fair, but I'm not smart, soooo? Thanks for the help

[zing]

Here's a happy trade

I don't think it's fair, but I'm not smart, soooo? Thanks for the help :mrgreen:

unfair to you,
their side adds up to almost a 2013 rare.

[Zelfie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73246319&userid=921063&signature=tIAbutxmwloeZA7Bgj0jTw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73246513&userid=921063&signature=IdMQjiCwX60MTRy3_Ulv9Q





Ahh please help.
Are any of these fair for UR grapes?

[Horror]

clicky <3
should I do this? I know this is more than fair, but how easy is it to get fair trades for the dogtag? I've had trouble with them in the past, so I don't know that they're worth the trouble unless it's gotten better in the past few months.

just got another;;
this?

if you are looking to trade down the dogtag, you probably won't get it's full worth.
3 nons is usually the highest the set goes for, but i personally wouldn't go for an dogtag for them.

thanks! what about the moonswirl?

The higher you go on the list the harder it is to get a trade down for any pet because less people can afford to trade up, and most of the people who can afford to don't want to. That's one of the reasons things like dogtags, sunjewels, or coontail go for underpay. Not that they're bad demand, it's that they're too expensive to get the full worth of. I personally don't value the set higher than a non, maybe up to two if a higher list pet is being involved rather than quantity lower lists. Frankly 3-4 nons is just greedy demand at this point as we all know those pets aren't worth that much, so if it were me at least I'd take it a dogtag, or at the very least consider it

[Smokey.Wolf]

Fair?