The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Horror]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73054439&userid=765419&signature=q7gsIQAsWE6wSLx-PerEaQ
Please somebody is this fair TuT?

Tier 2 advent = 4-5 09 rares
Your side = about 5.5 09 rares

A little bit of overpay on your side, I would at least take off one of the store pets

[Miss Biscuit~]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73060897&userid=845646&signature=VSVB_LGS-PbAlK8VrQUk9g
Is this fair? Im terrible with list pets ;^;

[Joof]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73060897&userid=845646&signature=VSVB_LGS-PbAlK8VrQUk9g
Is this fair? Im terrible with list pets ;^;

Unfair to you. The peas aren't placed yet, but their side is only worth a low main list (unless I missed something). Yours will probably placed somewhere around the gap on the main list (:

[Miss Biscuit~]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73060897&userid=845646&signature=VSVB_LGS-PbAlK8VrQUk9g
Is this fair? Im terrible with list pets ;^;

Unfair to you. The peas aren't placed yet, but their side is only worth a low main list (unless I missed something). Yours will probably placed somewhere around the gap on the main list (:

Okay, ty!

[Librho]

Could someone quickly help me with this?

Thank you so much if you can, I’m just unsure as they sent me a similar trade asking for two insisting it was overpay so I’d like another opinion to my own if possible to make sure what I’m thinking is correct and I’m not being unfair to them^^

Thank you so much again

Your 2018 store pet = late 2010 rare (or 4 2010 uncommons)
Their side is roughly worth half that so it's unfair to you

Ahh thank you so much^^

[Corey Taylor]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73061003&userid=781126&signature=ABkaVpTAIWQ-gRIcvpOS4Q

Is this fair ?

[spirited away]

x

i already asked if this fair, its unfair for her.
she said she doesn't care
i have two pit bul dog
should i say yes?

[nobxdy]

x

i already asked if this fair, its unfair for her.
she said she doesn't care
i have two pit bul dog
should i say yes?

Rarity wise they're overpaying. Your dog is only worth 1 '09 rare, and they're offering the worth of 2 '09 rares. Whether you want to accept is up to you.

[Joof]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73061003&userid=781126&signature=ABkaVpTAIWQ-gRIcvpOS4Q

Is this fair ?

Their side is worth about 7.5 '09 rares while your bun is worth 6-7 '09 rares and a '09 uncommon. So roughly fair, if at all slightly unfair to them (:

x

i already asked if this fair, its unfair for her.
she said she doesn't care
i have two pit bul dog
should i say yes?

I'd say it's fine to accept. You checked on fairness, told them it's not fair but they don't mind overpaying. So I personally would ^^

[spirited away]

x

fair?