The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[gentle snacc]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72798389&userid=819108&signature=5cROJ0MqHMEe7NpkRv2jbA Fair? Not really feeling it

i think 4 uncommon is work a rare,so it's not fair

[Black Clover]

is this fair??

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

Witch one would you take?
?
or
??
Dancing.cinnamon~
Warning: Bulk trade with items 481 items c:
2nd 700 and something

Please help!

[popping star]

Would you accept this? Thank you!

2008 very rares are worth way more then just a 2014 very rare!

yes, this pet is a ur, so it is a fair trade

Please don't give false advice.
It isn't fair to the main list. The UR ice cat is worth roughly 30 mid advents.
The bottom of the trade is only worth around 5 mid advents + a high advent.

[elnachos]

this??

[glass house]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72798389&userid=819108&signature=5cROJ0MqHMEe7NpkRv2jbA Fair? Not really feeling it

A 2017 rare is worth 4 2017 uncommons so this definitely isn't fair
to you although I'm not sure how many commons an uncommon is worth.

[gentle snacc]

Would you accept this? Thank you!

2008 very rares are worth way more then just a 2014 very rare!

Please don't give false advice. The other side is a UR Mainlist pet worth way more than the quantity side.

sorry about that i am not that good at trading,i shouldn't be giving out advise.

[nobxdy]

this??

I answered this yesterday, reposting incase you didn't see:

this??

Rarity wise, it's unfair to you. Their side adds up to about a Sorbet. The UR Flower Pot is worth 2 Sorbets + a Green Toxic, but generally goes for around 1-2 Sorbets demand wise. The Tribal also doesn't have the best demand, but it's up to you if you want to take the trade or not.

[elnachos]

this??

Rarity wise, it's unfair to you. Their side adds up to about a Sorbet. The UR Flower Pot is worth 2 Sorbets + a Green Toxic, but generally goes for around 1-2 Sorbets demand wise. The Tribal also doesn't have the best demand, but it's up to you if you want to take the trade or not.[/quote]

sorry, never saw. second opinions?

[Clawdina]

this??

(strictly rarity-wise) Unfair to the flower. The ur flower is worth about 2 sorbets and a green toxic. the gearback tribal is not worth a sorbet but the sept. lists just about fill the gap between the gearback tribal, so it adds up to a sorbet, which still leaves about a sorbet and green toxic.
(including demand) where you value the flower decides if this is a fair trade. From what I've seen, the ur flower only goes for about 1-1.5 sorbets so I would say this is a fairly decent trade