The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Fat Unicorn]

Trade

I'm not too good with the list. Is this fair?

Just to add; I have the toxics.

Their growing white july is above the gap and your toxics are below it, so I think they would either be overpaying or it's fair. Might want a second opinion to be more specific

Thanks!! Anyone else have any advice??

-snippity snip- Read some information wrong! Take negris' (technical) advice on the next page. ^^

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AyFTULPUYQ

does this seem fair? thanks in advance!

Doesn't seem fair to me pretty sure the Rose PPS is worth more, I could be wrong though so get another opinion aswell

I disagree, the RBM is worth more. ^^ They're overpaying technically.

[*Nevi Nova*]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72518577&userid=798259&signature=1TX_pDl1bv4LAyFTULPUYQ

does this seem fair? thanks in advance!

Doesn't seem fair to me pretty sure the Rose PPS is worth more, I could be wrong though so get another opinion aswell

The rose PPS is 5 tiers below the RBM, demand wise usually goes for same-tier trades, or a skeleton pps

[Lillekatt]

this?
thank you

[dddddonuts]

hey! i'm not too good with store pets' values, especially in mass quantities for lists. i'd totally appreciate some help in evaluating this trade here :-) thank you!

[theholygrell]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WvDCHXWy8g

Still looking for opinions on this trade! I don't know items well at all

[*Nevi Nova*]

Which trade would be best to accept, and why?
target dog for grinner +
Target dogfor celestial pps +
Target dog, pink balloon bun, and toxic bun, for winged blood dog

Also thanks to those who helped with my last trade!, and thanks to whoever will help with these

[popping star]

Fair? If not, who needs to add?

[Lorde.]

Could someone help me I have no clue if this is fair LOL
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kqrz4FcTjg

[StarWolfen]

**Unfair to you, sorry!
My first post was contradicting itself - It’s unfair to the 2012 store pet as it’s worth 2 ‘09 rares. The C$ is worth a 2011 rare and the 2017 store is worth a mid 2010 rare, so the bulk side needs to add about 3 2011 uncommons and an ‘09 rare.

Ohhh okay thank you so much !

[the]

Trade

I'm not too good with the list. Is this fair?

Just to add; I have the toxics.

Their growing white july is above the gap and your toxics are below it, so I think they would either be overpaying or it's fair. Might want a second opinion to be more specific

Thanks!! Anyone else have any advice??

It's currently unfair to them technically. ^^ A GWJ is worth roughly around 5 Green Toxics. You'd have to add roughly around a Balloon dog.

I disagree. The gap between the GWJ and the purple toxic is roughly a red toxic, not another purple toxic. Their pet has also low demand and goes for about 1.5-2 sorbets, so one of your purple toxics would be fair.
Earlier you got another opinion about this trade and I agree with this.

Trade

I'm not too good with the list. Is this fair?

unfair to you.
each purple toxic is worth 1.5 sorbets + an red x pps, which'd add up to an non + a little