How much you can get for a true date just depends on who you trade. Some people want true dates and will pay a little more, and other people don't care since it's just the exact same pet.
The cinnabun has no set value or worth so it's completely up to you on how you value it and what you're happy accepting.
I personally value it at a non or slightly above one, so in that case both would be overpaying, with the second one being worth significantly more.
Unfair to them
The 2011 pets + a 2012 common on your side just about covers one of their pets
Everything else only adds up to slightly over a 2012 uc
I paid a red x pps for one patchwork and a blue rose for another, and both were in auctions so I can't imagine the patchwork goes for much more than a high sept to maybe a low main list. Their side up just about adds up to a rainbow mane or slightly under so they would be overpaying
Rarity wise they're still overpaying since patchworks aren't actually worth that much
Byler. wrote:http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72753626&userid=904067&signature=QVEay66go9lJFPEqot6ttA
NEED IMIDIATE HELP
Demanding immediate help won't get it any quicker. If someone knows the answer they'll get to it as soon as they can.
Their uncommon warrior and yours are a perfectly fair swap rarity wise. Demand is completely up to you on which you prefer and if you're happy with this or not.