The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Guest]

Ok thanks!

[Sheena.b]

Would a 2014 store pet be fair for a 2009 rare sitting cat?

this is the trade
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FDzjcMWOmA


i think it is unfair

Yes,unfair to the store pet.The sitting cat is a late '09 rare when it should be a mid one.

so what does that mean? on the dog side it needs more pets?

[Sheena.b]

now is this fair?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mWm2-n3nqQ

[TzatzikiTheLeg]

Yes,unfair to the store pet.The sitting cat is a late '09 rare when it should be a mid one.

so what does that mean? on the dog side it needs more pets?[/quote]
No,the side with the cat needs to add a '09 uncommon.

[MOVED !!!]

Would a 2014 store pet be fair for a 2009 rare sitting cat?
this is the trade
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FDzjcMWOmA

2014 storepet = mid 09' rare. - Their cat is a late 09' rare, but unless you both care about months, this is a fair swap. (though, those dog-storepets are quite liked, and can fetch another 09-10' rare added if the person is looking for it.)

now is this fair?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mWm2-n3nqQ

Unfair to you, like I said, 2014 storepet - mid 09' rare
(they would have to replace the two 11' uncommons with two 10' uncommons.)
( most value like this ; 4 uncommons = 1 rare (same year)

I'd personally decline and trade for a 09' rare.

[Osborn]

the nondog is true date, could I possibly get more than it’s worth for it? They added as well. Please help, I’m not very updated on what the cinnabun goes for
also, this
trade, which is better?

?

[the chariot]

Hi. I'm not certain with bulk trades and date gaps, since I just recently returned. Is this fair?

Thank you!

I'd say its unfair to the bottom a bit?

Agreed! Their side is worth a 2014 uncommon/2013 common + a 2017(ish) uncommon, so it’s unfair to you.

Thank you both!

[Pyca]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72751121&userid=933497&signature=uTtQGXirjZIp4OQBiLs2gw

I'm not too good with the list. Is this fair?

[Lorde.]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fhPbfn_wHg

[Concrete Jungle]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=72752508
?