The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[3000feet]

I don't usually trade or collect pets at all unless I like the look of them, but can someone please let me know about the balance of this trade as of right now?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HukeDGw5HA

I'm not sure exactly but your zebra is a high main list and the grown white July dog is considerably lower on the main list by comparison. I don't think those store pets are enough to bridge the gap. I believe they would be underpaying but I'm not certain by exactly how much. I would personally want a high-ish september or very low main along with the white July.

[abbobi]

i know nothing about the value of items... http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72523545&userid=211348&signature=muNq_Ukp1jzhs7bkdQcdqQ

so i've now received 4 new trades for the 2011 summer map since posting the above^... but no one responded to give me an estimate of the value of it. (i've since cancelled the above trade since it is clearly worth more than that.)

I'm now looking at either-
1. advent list dogtag bun
2. an '09 rare and two '15 rares
3. advent list blue snowflake scarf dog
4. an '09 rare tess dragon with request to edit

which of these is the best offer and/or what should I add to the 4th trade to make it fair?

[JackRabbitWonderous]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rUjX0v55TA
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gWM6Ya_YZg
How are these two? I don't know the rarity of my dog ah

[Fizzy-Pop]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6oaqeVQtEw

Fair?

[magician,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B3zl90EHTQ
Is This Fair?
~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pWKU-9Mv3w
Fair?
~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c-71lu1WDA
Fair?
~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 63RcenYV_A
Fair?
~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SYIQEvNO6A
Fair?

[the]

i know nothing about the value of items... http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72523545&userid=211348&signature=muNq_Ukp1jzhs7bkdQcdqQ

so i've now received 4 new trades for the 2011 summer map since posting the above^... but no one responded to give me an estimate of the value of it. (i've since cancelled the above trade since it is clearly worth more than that.)

I'm now looking at either-
1. advent list dogtag bun
2. an '09 rare and two '15 rares
3. advent list blue snowflake scarf dog
4. an '09 rare tess dragon with request to edit

which of these is the best offer and/or what should I add to the 4th trade to make it fair?

You shouldn't accept any of them, the map is very valuable and can go for much more. You should ask about another opinion how much exactly you can get for it, but it's at least a mid-high september list

[Gubler]

Is this bid fair?
Thank you so much in advance c:

[abbobi]

i know nothing about the value of items... http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72523545&userid=211348&signature=muNq_Ukp1jzhs7bkdQcdqQ

so i've now received 4 new trades for the 2011 summer map since posting the above^... but no one responded to give me an estimate of the value of it. (i've since cancelled the above trade since it is clearly worth more than that.)

I'm now looking at either-
1. advent list dogtag bun
2. an '09 rare and two '15 rares
3. advent list blue snowflake scarf dog
4. an '09 rare tess dragon with request to edit

which of these is the best offer and/or what should I add to the 4th trade to make it fair?

You shouldn't accept any of them, the map is very valuable and can go for much more. You should ask about another opinion how much exactly you can get for it, but it's at least a mid-high september list

thanks! any second opinions?

[stag]

fair?

[the]

fair?

Very unfair to you, the grinner is worth 13-17 rares '09 while their is worth only 3.