The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ranger of the North]

Kia ora! Are any of these fair? If so, which is best? Thank you! C:

[husky.]

roughly how many c$ are these pets worth?

[♥LilPeep♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72533404&userid=877119&signature=zpdEMYX2kCOsBF0IDDX5ew

Help, ASAP please.

[Mythz]

BMD + ? = UR Zonkey?

Thank you ^^

[♥LilPeep♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72533655&userid=877119&signature=TVHe-E-RH845N8kpAlSdaw

How’s this? I need help on the other post too. ^^^

[Fat Unicorn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72533655&userid=877119&signature=TVHe-E-RH845N8kpAlSdaw

How’s this? I need help on the other post too. ^^^

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72533404&userid=877119&signature=zpdEMYX2kCOsBF0IDDX5ew

Help, ASAP please.

A 2014 store pet is roughly worth around a mid '09 rare, so it's unfair to them. ^^ If you need help on multiple trades, it's probably best to put them in the same post so we see both!

For the second trade, it's also unfair to them.

[NineVulpine]

Anybody good with big older item trades? I've got no clue on this one. @_@

[husky.]

roughly how many c$ are these pets worth?

also, is this at all fair?

[Horror]

roughly how many c$ are these pets worth?

also, is this at all fair?

C$ questions belong here for your first question. Though since all the pets were free/anyone and everyone can adopt them they most likely won't be over uncommon, and anything uncommon/under doesn't have a set C$ worth, so it's just up to you on how you actually value them yourself.
Second trade is unfair to you due to the large age gap between your pets and theirs. You have 3 2011 uncommons while they only have 1 plus some pets that are too recent to make up the gap

Kia ora! Are any of these fair? If so, which is best? Thank you! C:

First one is fair to both sides if we do the 3 month rule across years
Second and third are overpay on the other sides as the tess horses are each worth a mid 09 rare and the zodiac is only a 2010 rare. The third one has added uncommons while the second one is just a straight swap, so the third trade would be the better one

[Pickaxe]

Hi! Would a UR Aussie/Cookie for a July PPS be a fair trade demand wise? I know the PPS is a tier above, but I don't really know about demand (seems low for my UR actually as I don't receive much demand).
Thank's ^^