The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Freeway]

x

So I just got this as a bid in my auction and I absolutely love the pets, but how fair is it to me? Lots of thanks in advance to anyone who can help! c:

[ANETRA]

i am holding an auction for two uncommon warrior cats. the bids i've received all seem good and about equal but i honestly don't know
where do these bids stand in terms of value, both rarity and demand wise? which one(s) would be the best in helping me trade for a zodiac dog?

viewtopic.php?f=40&t=3785676&p=118047854#p118047854

thanks!

[elnachos]

how about now??

still very unfair. The shima butterflywolf is worth 11 mid advents and the red toxic is worth 63. the rares is worth 3 mid advents and the c$ is worth a target dog at the most and it's worth 2 mid advents & 2 '09 rares. so their side is worth about 16 mid advents.

Thanks! Second opinion?

[yeontan.o]

x

So I just got this as a bid in my auction and I absolutely love the pets, but how fair is it to me? Lots of thanks in advance to anyone who can help! c:

It's not that fair the PPS malk is worth 1 sorbet, the chesire is worth a mid advent. But the UR foal is worth 2 sorbets as I was told

[MoonDriveZee]

How's this? <3

[nobxdy]

x

So I just got this as a bid in my auction and I absolutely love the pets, but how fair is it to me? Lots of thanks in advance to anyone who can help! c:

It's not that fair the PPS malk is worth 1 sorbet, the chesire is worth a mid advent. But the UR foal is worth 2 sorbets as I was told

The PPS Malk is not worth 1 Sorbet, and the UR Foal is not worth 2 Sorbets. The PPS Malk is worth 11 Mid Advents, and the UR Foal is worth 1.5 Sorbets + a Red-X PPS. However, demand may cause them to go for more.

[Horror]

Would a ClockWork Bunny Be A Fair Trade For A Sept List Angel Advent?

dillydally

Rarity wise not at all, the angel advent is worth quite a bit more.
"Demand" depends on who you trade and how you both value the clockwork bun at. I personally value it at 2 mid advents as that's the value of what I paid for my clockwork but everyone values things differently

Would a Sockdog be fair for the Hollyfox? If not, what should be added to either side to make it fair?

Sockdog = 10 09 rares
Hollyfox = 6-7

Rarity wise the hollyfox needs to add about a tier 1 advent
"Demand" completely depends on who you trade and how you both value the hollyfox

Is this fair?? Thanks for any help ^^

Floppy sept = 5 mid advents + a low advent or roughly around 34-45 09 rares give or take
Their side adds up to roughly around 23 09 rares or just about a pink stripe sept tier so they need to add a bit more
If you're willing to overpay for quantity or take underpay for your pink sept then that is up to you

quick answers would be nice :>!

>> http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hdnTX7HpAg

>> http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... s7g8VPVZ6A

>> http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IXTq3w710A

I'm not very good with this sorta stuff, so I would get a second opinion.

The first one is overpay, as their side is worth 10-11 '09 rares while the grinner is only a tier 2 September.

The second I'm not so sure about

The third I'm not sure about either, but most of the pets on their side have quite low demand, so rarity wise it could possibly be fair, but it would be difficult to trade them away.

I'm not sure if that first statement is correct.. I was told by a staff member that the grinner is worth 14 '09 rares.

Looking for a second opinion !

The grinner and anything on it's tier is more worth about 13-17 09 rares as a range since you can't really put an exact worth on pets, though 14 is still in between there
So using grinner/halloween cat tier = 13-17 09 rares each or 2 mid advents + an early 09 rare each

1. First trade = about 12 09 rares or just roughly 2 mid advents so they need to add an early 09 rare more
2. Second trade = roughly a high advent list or about 9 09 rares, they need to add roughly a low advent list
3. Third trade = about 8 09 rares or a mid - high advent so it's also unfair to you

[Freeway]

x

So I just got this as a bid in my auction and I absolutely love the pets, but how fair is it to me? Lots of thanks in advance to anyone who can help! c:

It's not that fair the PPS malk is worth 1 sorbet, the chesire is worth a mid advent. But the UR foal is worth 2 sorbets as I was told

The PPS Malk is not worth 1 Sorbet, and the UR Foal is not worth 2 Sorbets. The PPS Malk is worth 11 Mid Advents, and the UR Foal is worth 1.5 Sorbets + a Red-X PPS. However, demand may cause them to go for more.

-- never mind, this final question was a dumb one --

[pochita]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I66FWp9l9A

Is this fair? Thanks for any answers!
- Cloverfern

[Grand Dragon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AewHlH-IRw

Does the lion normally get more than this?