The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[skyline]

could i get some thoughts on this? thanks in advance!! <3

[sumatra.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aiTDXM4-Hw

Is this fair?

[serik]

Ahhh, which one is better demand wise?? this? or this??

I mean I love the green lion tail so much but does it equal gwj + ur foal + vixen ??

[- Alice -]

is this one fair? Unsure due to demand ;-;

[serik]

Ahhh, which one is better demand wise?? this? or this??

I mean I love the green lion tail so much but does it equal gwj + ur foal + vixen ??

[sumatra.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aiTDXM4-Hw

Is this fair?

[magician,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9f6WrMzt4Q
~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... X83g1z65Dw
~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GZJsznuvJA
~
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HZEbte4Tmg

Are Any Of These Fair?? {Should I Edit Some Of Them??}

[Red-Headed Anole]

Fair?

[dibidibidis]

Ahhh, which one is better demand wise?? this? or this??

I mean I love the green lion tail so much but does it equal gwj + ur foal + vixen ??

In my own experience, the GLT can reach 2 sorbs to a non.
The GWJ is an absolute pain to trade off unless trading up as partial to high mains (ie. dogtag). If you're patient you might be able to get 1-2 sorbs for it.
The Foal goes for fair trades (2 sorbs) with patience, but it doesn't have great demand.
Personally I'd take the GLT trade, but if you have the patience, go with the GWJ + Foal.

Might want to get a second opinion though; I might just be unlucky. xD

[Meduz]

Is this bid fair? Demand wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... e2UKSspjwg
Also this one
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kOYNRs0rYA

demand wise. the red x is a september list and as well the dog with a pink ballon is a list. the red x is bumped up higher than the bmd

Thanks may I get a second opinion

Demand wise the BMD is worth about a balloon dog, though usually slightly more. Both of these are within that range. Rarity wise the second trade is a better offer. The UR ice cat is higher on this list and the add is fairly decent demand. The add on the first trade (Red X dog and cobweb bun) isn't worth more than the gap between the balloon and the ice cat. (Unless I've missed something.)
Demand wise, I'd say everything (but the BMD) goes for fairish trades. So the ice cat offer is better.
(The balloon dog is super popular though so may fetch some overpay but I'm not sure on this)