The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[teabug]

hello! ♡

im just wondering if this is a fair swap or if i/they would need to add more! thank you for your time !! ♡

[Moonshadow3]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NdK-9FVVUw

[mileagehaze]

I'm terrible with item rarity ;w;

[Dawnstorm111]

I'm not sure how much older storepets are worth, but is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71339886&userid=894335&signature=We1KI1i0nbDhwOkdLzVw6w

2015 store pets are worth ‘09 rares

[Horsesrule5000]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... X4JyaKcd1A
▪thank you▪

[teabug]

hello! ♡

im just wondering if this is a fair swap or if i/they would need to add more! thank you for your time !! ♡

[FOUND VERDICT]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... X4JyaKcd1A
▪thank you▪

rarity wise overpay.
but demandwise i wouldn't do it. the july pps can be a bit tricky to trade down und usually goes for 1.5 nons.
your side definitely has the better demand, with the lolita going for up to an sorbet too from what i've seen

[mileagehaze]

I'm terrible with item rarity ;w;

[Onyxeva]

I'm terrible with item rarity ;w;

Unfair to them. The mask on their side is worth around a 2011 uncommon, and the winter coat a 2012 uncommon.
You would have needed to add another 2015 rare and at least a late 2011 uncommon.

[mileagehaze]

I'm terrible with item rarity ;w;

Unfair to them. The mask on their side is worth around a 2011 uncommon, and the winter coat a 2012 uncommon.
You would have needed to add another 2015 rare and at least a late 2011 uncommon.

Oh!! Okay!! Second Opinion?