The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dogtreat]

hi there! i'm working on a trade that i'm kind of confused by since im still learning fair trading and i reeally don't understand UCs and C values - i think this is pretty close to fair? but im not too sure how close exactly
thank you for the help :3

the sorbet bun = 6-7 '09 rares + 09 uncommon

their side = ~4 total '09 rares i'd say. maybe 5 with the extra C$

it'd be unfair to you.

Would this be a fair trade? If not, could I get some advice on what could be added to make it more even?

okay someone might need to double check my math here lmao
i put the trade into '14 uncommons worth because of their side
((wherein each of their rares = 4 uncommons of the previous year))

their side = 26 '14 uncommons
your side = ~42 '14 uncommons

it'd be unfair to you imo.
however trading bulk uncommons for rares of later years is hard sometimes,
because most people would want rares for rares.
still yeah, mathematically unfair.

[Applenz]

I would appreciate some opinions on this trade.

[General Chaos]

Is this trade fair?

And this trade?

Thank you!!

[herbivore]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0UIUJQhx4Q

is this a fair trade??

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71203545&userid=915647&signature=sty2N45Zn6kL0UIUJQhx4Q

is this a fair trade??

Unfair to them, their cat is worth 2 09 rares and your dog is worth half of 1

[klaus hargreeves]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71194818&userid=865945&signature=AUOdEcAqR02wJKurMaivaQ
real quick how fair is this


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71193966&userid=865945&signature=bEeelT0L3IGbp3Y-JqcyBA

and this

[PinkSugar]

Hello! Is this fair?
(I'm pretty sure the caterpillar has a strangely high demand? From what I heard?)

A HUGE thanks to anyone who helps me! ❤

[nobxdy]

Hello! Is this fair?
(I'm pretty sure the caterpillar has a strangely high demand? From what I heard?)

A HUGE thanks to anyone who helps me! ❤

This has been answered 3 times already. The last person said this:

unfair to their side. evne if it does have higher demand, its not worth an early 2010 rare.

[Thovatos]

Ugh. I really shouldn't do trades like these because they spike the demand of a raven. I've tried similar trades like this for a sunback, sunjewel, moonswirl, and even the UR BW. Are the demand on Zebras and C$ so bad when trading for lists, even huge overpay ins't even considered?

[PinkSugar]

Hello! Is this fair?
(I'm pretty sure the caterpillar has a strangely high demand? From what I heard?)

A HUGE thanks to anyone who helps me! ❤

This has been answered 3 times already. The last person said this:

unfair to their side. evne if it does have higher demand, its not worth an early 2010 rare.

I don't understand it. And 3 opinions still doesn't help when I have other people saying differently.