The “Is this a fair trade?” thread

[the]

[quotel

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70933996&userid=880728&signature=btauUme2NyZZIYAt0lTzQQ

Is this fair?

their pet is worth about one mid 09 rare, so a bit unfair to you
just two of your pets should be fair by rarity

'13 store pet is worth two '16 store pets, so third '17 store pet would fill the gap between '17 and '16 store pets. it was around fair rarity wise in my opinion. if we consider good demand of the kitsune masks, i'd say even unfair to them demand wise

a 2013 store pet is worth about a mid 09 rare. a 2017 store pet is worth a mid 2010 rare
The three store pets together are worth an 08 rare+, not a 2009 rare (aka the store pet)

[/quote]
'13 store pet is worth early '09 now. two '17 store pets are worth mid rare '09, and third store pet is worth 4 uc '10 (2 uc '09). the gap is usually uncommon '09, so in total there's early rare '09 + uc '09

[Sweet flower!]

Are the 1650 items fair for the cobweb bun

[mierose]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d0yluS-eog
Should I accept?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

^^ I value the store pets a little differently because people seem to be increasing their values a lot faster than we did in the past, and I personally don't agree with it based on my experience. But some people still value them based on what they are told, and thats totally okay! Just not what I do
But even with your explanation, they are overpaying. They gap between a mid 09 rare and an early is like a 2010 uncommon or two, not a 2010 rare.
But I will agree to disagree, rarities aren't a perfect science and it all depends on how each person sees it c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70933889&userid=919083&signature=3us2qZ-fq1KKCsb0QYIScg

nothing special but is this fair?

looks okay to me
Each of the items is from the 2011 summer event, and worth about a mid 2011 uncommon each. So look fair c:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70934275&userid=716199&signature=bm4PJIsQPPLdd0yluS-eog
Should I accept?

Depends on how much you value the zodiac.
The 2016 store pets roughly cancel each other out. The other two pets are worth about 2 mid-late 09 rares or so.
If you value the zodiac at 1 09 rare, unfair to you. If you value it at 2, its about fair ^^

[Sweet flower!]

is this fair?

[GhostPants]

This was sent XXX
Taking demand into mind how is it? I havent gotten many trades for my tox so maybe the purples demand went down?
And i know that all tribals have bad demand.. So i dont know? Im not very great at list pets ;u;
@Gasoline
EDIT: hnnnng another one XXX

[lp04158]

Not sure... help! Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... U3AQuBWqlQ

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

is this fair?

no link ^^

This was sent XXX
Taking demand into mind how is it? I havent gotten many trades for my tox so maybe the purples demand went down?
And i know that all tribals have bad demand.. So i dont know? Im not very great at list pets ;u;
@Gasoline
EDIT: hnnnng another one XXX

1. unfair to the toxic. Their side is worth about a red toxic roughly. The toxic has lower demand but it can still get close to fair trades
2. even more unfair to you ^^

Not sure... help! Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... U3AQuBWqlQ

unfair to them, just the 2010 uncommon is overpay due to the large gap in years c:

[KryativeLotus]

Which one is better?

• BID 1
• BID 2

Is this and this fair?

STAY KRYATIVE

[Ranger of the North]

Kia Ora, are either of these okay? Thanks again! c: