The “Is this a fair trade?” thread

[Hyensa]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rdZFKcIgXQ

Help please?

[Fwutter]

can someone please help me with this?

It's unfair to the top rarity wise, demand wise, it would take A LOT of patience to get those pets back. I wouldn't really ever give that much for a tribal

[popping star]

can someone please help me with this?

It's unfair to the top rarity wise, demand wise, it would take A LOT of patience to get those pets back. I wouldn't really ever give that much for a tribal

Agreed. The Tribal has bad demand, so it's hard to get a decent amount of quantity back.

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70752084&userid=470278&signature=r5yvNO1nm0vRrdZFKcIgXQ

Help please?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70752084&userid=470278&signature=r5yvNO1nm0vRrdZFKcIgXQ

Help please?

it's fair as the scarf dog is worth 3-4 '09 rares. The uncommons aren't needed.

[wanderlust,]

can someone please help me with this?

It's unfair to the top rarity wise, demand wise, it would take A LOT of patience to get those pets back. I wouldn't really ever give that much for a tribal

Agreed. The Tribal has bad demand, so it's hard to get a decent amount of quantity back.

i agree with everyone above. i had a line tribal before and they are very hard to trade off. i would definitely consider asking for a trade back

[September Rain]

Of course, so sorry about the wait !! I personally wouldn't accept but that's because I've heard each of the punk dogs can get a balloon dog (except the Lolita which can get a sorbet) and their cake dog is a mid September. But do get another opinion on that as that is based off of what other players have said, not from experience (:


i've never seen the orange, pink, and yellow punk dogs go for more than an advent, they could go for more than their worth but definitely not a mainlist. the trade is unfair to the cake dog.

Agreed. The most I've seen a punk go for is a low september and that's only with the white lolita. Even though cake dogs don't have the best of demands, it's still unfair to them.

Thank you guys so much!

Edit: How is this in comparison? How's the Hyena's demand? (Original trade)

[gallifrey falls.]

@tribal discussion, If you say something has poor demand that just helps spread the fact it does. Then people won't be able to trade their pet fairly and get the full value of what its worth. I'm struggling to trade my Gearback Tribal for that reason; people keep telling me it has bad demand so they don't want to trade up, even when I'm asking for much less than its worth.
It's a good idea to consider demand when trading but don't let that devalue the pet I guess is what I'm trying to say. Sorry for the length!

[olduser12345678910]

is this fair rarity wise? what about demand wise?

[.Animal.]

Are either of these fair?
Trade One

Trade Two

[cattle dog]

how is this?

or this?