The “Is this a fair trade?” thread

[Silverstar]

Opinions on this bid?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0lhyPSb6vw

And this bid?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 60b6OXUzqg

both trades are unfair to them.
The first trade is worth 12.5 '09 rares while your advent is worth only 7-8.
as for the second trade, 95 C$ is worth a hyena. Plus the other pets = 9-10 '09 rares.

[wanderlust,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70751565&userid=798259&signature=bSlsW6EwI4rD59N3l8kLdw

i know zebras have iffy demand so can i get opinions? thank in advance c:

Well lets see. The ur fox and the zebra basically go for 1-2 nons so they cancel out then the GWJ is extreme overpay for the other two pets so i'd say this is exxtremely unfair to you, try to get a second opinion in case im wrong though >-<

thank you!

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70752084&userid=470278&signature=r5yvNO1nm0vRrdZFKcIgXQ

Help please?

it's fair as the scarf dog is worth 3-4 '09 rares. The uncommons aren't needed.

[rottenyeen]

Helpety help ples

[moosetachio]

Is this fair? How are the demand of these pets? Could I possibly get more, or is this above average?


Of course, so sorry about the wait !! I personally wouldn't accept but that's because I've heard each of the punk dogs can get a balloon dog (except the Lolita which can get a sorbet) and their cake dog is a mid September. But do get another opinion on that as that is based off of what other players have said, not from experience (:


i've never seen the orange, pink, and yellow punk dogs go for more than an advent, they could go for more than their worth but definitely not a mainlist. the trade is unfair to the cake dog.

Agreed. The most I've seen a punk go for is a low september and that's only with the white lolita. Even though cake dogs don't have the best of demands, it's still unfair to them.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70751821&userid=910149&signature=YYHD9qlrntI39ahAo5urLw

Is a 2011 uncommon horse underpay for the four current monthly dragons? Or am I overpaying them?

Unfair to you. Say the dragons will be uncommons. Their side would only be worth an early '17 uncommon and '18 uncommon. But most people don't like trading their newborns.

[XxMudkip77xX]

Helpety help ples

Unfair to the ur fox alone. The zebras usually go for 3 nons but bad demand has them going for 1-2 nons which is exactly what the ur fox goes for. All the added pets is extreme undepay on the zebra.

[cattle dog]

how is this?

or this?

[rottenyeen]

Helpety help ples

Unfair to the ur fox alone. The zebras usually go for 3 nons but bad demand has them going for 1-2 nons which is exactly what the ur fox goes for. All the added pets is extreme undepay fon the zebra.

Okie dokie thank ye!

[pigeon.enthusiast]

can someone please help me with this?

[popping star]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70751565&userid=798259&signature=bSlsW6EwI4rD59N3l8kLdw

i know zebras have iffy demand so can i get opinions? thank in advance c:

Well lets see. The ur fox and the zebra basically go for 1-2 nons so they cancel out then the GWJ is extreme overpay for the other two pets so i'd say this is exxtremely unfair to you, try to get a second opinion in case im wrong though >-<

thank you!

I agree with it being unfair to the UR fox side. The GWJ is an above gap main list that's worth 2 sorbets + a ur apple. It may get underpay, but it's still overpay for the other two pets.