The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.catastrophe.crow.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70588485&userid=875611&signature=B5dNeuuqlZ-TDEMnPcziVQ
URGENT!
Is this a fair trade? Thanks!

[qbaiter]

help?

[Keen]

Is this fair?

Help please? Don't want to keep them waiting too long ;-;

[rottenyeen]

Is this fair?

Help please? Don't want to keep them waiting too long ;-;

They're undertrading, as recent store pets usually go for 1-2 09' rares. Even with the other pets and items, it's still unfair. Items in my opinion are also harder to trade off.

[agust]

Is this fair?

They're undertrading, as recent store pets usually go for 1-2 09' rares. Even with the other pets and items, it's still unfair. Items in my opinion are also harder to trade off.

I disagree. The store pets only go for a 2010 rare each.

[rottenyeen]

Is this fair?

They're undertrading, as recent store pets usually go for 1-2 09' rares. Even with the other pets and items, it's still unfair. Items in my opinion are also harder to trade off.

I disagree. The store pets only go for a 2010 rare each.

omg whoops I swear
I didn't realize they were 12/18's! Ignore what I said
(i've personally gotten offered 09's for my january store pets)

[rottenyeen]

What would they have to add for this?

They're offering this now
Clicky!

[Sharpwater]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70588485&userid=875611&signature=B5dNeuuqlZ-TDEMnPcziVQ
URGENT!
Is this fair for either? Thanks a lot!

Im pretty sure that you would need to add a few rares from around 2016

[Keen]

Is this fair?

They're undertrading, as recent store pets usually go for 1-2 09' rares. Even with the other pets and items, it's still unfair. Items in my opinion are also harder to trade off.

I disagree. The store pets only go for a 2010 rare each.

Okay so... What is the consensus here? I didn't really understand this convo XD

[Snailsy]

Would this be fair? The dog is from Sep '09