The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[snowdrake]

Okay so i need someone who's really good with items and big trades. this has a grand total of 4184 items, is it fair to my red toxic and is the red toxic fair for the items? thank you for any response or help given, i really appreciate it!

personally, I wouldn't accept it. they might have a huge quantity as an offer, but there are barely any valuable items. if I'm not mistaken, not a single one of their items is worth a 09 rare. you can get a better item quantity for a mainlist pet, I believe. however, this is just my point of view, it's probably best if you get a few more opinions.

[AzureDreams<3]

Thanks okeke!

Could I have help with this trade too? Would you personally do it (considering that tribals aren't easy to trade off)? Thank you!

- snip -

Thank you again! I'm leaning towards doing that. Could I have a second opinion just to be sure?

[.catastrophe.crow.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70576589&userid=875611&signature=Y4eWgNS7-asXiRx6oXD48Q

Is this fair? Thanks!!

[Tara_Markov]

I am aware that this is unfair to them rarity wise, but what about demand? Thanks!

[dillydallydarlene]

Help I don't know which would be best to go with......


1. Toxic
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D8uYk6dXLQ

2. Orange Sherbert list & UR Apple http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a1Pi4rVZig

3. Edit of ur apple trade
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1wb8HaUhFg

4. Blue Rose dog
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YlaULvs31w

5. Love the Bulk 2009 bulk wise is very impressive. Lots of rats
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mMJTdo6WPA

6. Carousel horse http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xtrTimyMbg

7. Candy cane dog & 2009 PPS http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3CPoGffEKA

I’d take the toxic trade, it’s the highest list out of all the trades and has the best demand out of all the toxics.

Thank you for your response 😄

May I get a second opinion?
(I wanna make sure everything is solid with this)


Opinions went towards

Opinion 1. Toxic (this opinion was made before addition of UR Apple)

Opinion 2. Toxic (after addition or UR Apple)

Opinion 3. Toxic (after addition of UR Apple



Adding 2 more Opinions cause the person with the Ur apple edited


Opinion 4.

Opinion 5.

[AstralFire]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RHbXPEOD9w

your rat is worth 5 - 6 '09 rares.
the zodiac and the sitting cat easily fetch a '09 rare each, so i believe this is technically fair if not over on their side.

Thank you for your help

[Al3xand3r]

How many 2009 rares would equal to the new storepets?

[shelter.]

thoughts?

how's the demand of tribals (and toxics, for that matter)?

i know the tribal is two tiers higher, but does it usually go for fair stuff?

toxics go for fair trades,
and tribals go for underpay.

to be honest i'd personally stick with the toxic. the tribal is going to be really hard to trade off.

thank you <3

a second opinion, just to make sure?

[zing]

How many 2009 rares would equal to the new storepets?

the store pets are worth a late '10 rare each,
so one '09 rare alone is overpay.

[ThunderCedar]

thoughts?

how's the demand of tribals (and toxics, for that matter)?

i know the tribal is two tiers higher, but does it usually go for fair stuff?

toxics go for fair trades,
and tribals go for underpay.

to be honest i'd personally stick with the toxic. the tribal is going to be really hard to trade off.

thank you <3

a second opinion, just to make sure?

If you want a personal opinion, then,
I agree. I would not take this either.