The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[GreenteaLatte]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HMHpxunWZg

Is this fair?
I don't know what the store pets are worth...

[Cherubic]

Is this okay? I'm not entirely sure how much seal PPS are worth and a nondate isn't exactly the same is it?

Also, this one?

[shisho]

Help me please with
this trade ! Horse is mine


i value a rare at 3 uncommons so they'd need to add another '10 uncommon, and possibly also another '10 uncommon to cover the month gap.
so they'd need to add 2 '10 uncommons.

[froggy.satan]

XXX is this fair? I know zodiacs demand varies from person to person but i value it at around an 08 rare or very rare


On the other side of this, Plus been asking for awhile now

[Katzilla]

XXX is this fair? I know zodiacs demand varies from person to person but i value it at around an 08 rare or very rare


On the other side of this, Plus been asking for awhile now

It depends on how much you value the zodiac dogs at, so demand wise I'm not sure. Rarity wise the side with store pets are worth more.

[pigeon -]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70353562&userid=224744&signature=HuWQud3Ibc1AHMHpxunWZg

Is this fair?
I don't know what the store pets are worth...

the store pets are an '09 rare so at the moment their side adds to 8 '09 rare
plus the butterfly wolf rare which I think is '09 as well but can't remember off the top
of my head. In any case your list pet is 7-8 '09 rares and with their side having at least
8 possibly nine they are overpaying with the butterfly wolf anyway c:

[Katzilla]

Help me please with
this trade ! Horse is mine

It's fair if you value a rare at 2 uncommons (which most people do ^^)

[AudreyPotter]

Help me please with
this trade ! Horse is mine


i value a rare at 3 uncommons so they'd need to add another '10 uncommon, and possibly also another '10 uncommon to cover the month gap.
so they'd need to add 2 '10 uncommons.

'10 uncommon='12 rare

2 '12 rare= 1 '11 rare

so yeah they would need to add another '11 rare worth which is another 2 '10 uncommon(:

thats how i work it out(:
xoxo

[LostForever]

Help me please with
this trade ! Horse is mine

It's fair if you value a rare at 2 uncommons (which most people do ^^)

Actually you will find it very hard to trade two uncommons for a rare

[xNocturnalKittenX]

I also just got this one I'd like help with as well. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oCkYf7fwfQ ;v; I'd really like to get the rat and knock some other WL pets off, but the large gap in years of the other pets are throwing me off. If this is unfair what should be added to balance it?