The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[icyhot]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70081564&userid=789504&signature=3ROnYhXgnu0n0uXeEW3E_g

Is this Fair?

[Bubbled Aurora]

[uote="TheLittleBlackCat"]

Hey i was bidding on a ur tess horse and i actually won was is actually fair tho?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YI1bWW02rw

Well, I don’t know Rarity wise, yet demand wise it was very unfair to you. Tess horse<Warrior Cats. They have a way better demand. Tess horses have really bad demand.

yes i understand but can i get a more proper opinion please?

unfair to the tess horse rarity wise as the purple tess horse is a mainlist (granted it's a low mainlist and many people tend to dislike it)

I've occasionally seen full sets of warrior cats going for a high advent- high sept though there are some exceptions from time to time where they can go for more than that (the key word being "can", the sets aren't guarenteed to go for much higher but can go for higher if someone's desperately searching for the set)

Edit: also, if I'm correct, your side wasn't a complete set

was it?[/quote]

no just 15 warriors

[lucky333123]

i'm so so tempted with this one! could i please have an opinion or two about it? thank you in advance! ^,^

I know that your pet is equivalent to a non coon. This trade is fair since rarity wise, it’s over pay on their side, and demand wise fair because they all pretty much have the same demand.

Thank you! Second opinions?

Please do not give false advice. It is unfair to the bottom. Their side will add up to less than a single sorbet. Your dog is worth three sorbets.

[Ꭺlina]

i'm so so tempted with this one! could i please have an opinion or two about it? thank you in advance! ^,^

Thank you! Second opinions?

Please do not give false advice. It is unfair to the bottom. Their side will add up to less than a single sorbet. Your dog is worth three sorbets.

agreeing on this.

[miilk]

i'm so so tempted with this one! could i please have an opinion or two about it? thank you in advance! ^,^

I know that your pet is equivalent to a non coon. This trade is fair since rarity wise, it’s over pay on their side, and demand wise fair because they all pretty much have the same demand.

Thank you! Second opinions?

Please do not give false advice. It is unfair to the bottom. Their side will add up to less than a single sorbet. Your dog is worth three sorbets.[/quote]

When I asked the thread a little while back, they said it would be a fair swap for the noncoon & their pet. And the non coon is worth the ballon dog set. Was I given false advice?

[lilystar]

Can I have some opinions on this bid? I'm looking for quantity for red x pps
60 pets - 33 rares, 12 Store pets
40 pets, all store

[Ꭺlina]

When I asked the thread a little while back, they said it would be a fair swap for the noncoon & their pet. And the non coon is worth the ballon dog set. Was I given false advice?

yes, you were given false advice. It’s always important to get more than one opinion because there are a lot of people giving wrong advice on here

[icyhot]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70081564&userid=789504&signature=3ROnYhXgnu0n0uXeEW3E_g

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70082354&userid=789504&signature=6f5EtsGsuM0m808qTs5-nQ

Are these both fair? They're both wanting the PPS Malk 2009 Owl

[Charizard !]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uek58pD_lA

how is this?

[Bubbled Aurora]

When I asked the thread a little while back, they said it would be a fair swap for the noncoon & their pet. And the non coon is worth the ballon dog set. Was I given false advice?

yes, you were given false advice. It’s always important to get more than one opinion because there are a lot of people giving wrong advice on here

why do people even give false advice?