The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[miyuuma]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fWCVSSA-A

This is not the final Trade, they want me to add more VRs/Rares to the trade, so I'm considering adding another 2015 VR Store pet (that raccoon-thing) to it, but I'm not quite sure how fair that trade is...any opinions?

The Pony is from August 2009 btw, it's a re-release tho.

[alpenglow]

offer 1

would this be fair to me? should I edit the trade at all?

offer 2

got another offer. also said they could offer their green toxic.

offer 3

yet another offer! said they would also offer their peach

[sɪᴍᴘʟɪᴄɪᴛʏ]

Hello~
Link
What would need to be added to fill the gap between the Wolf PPS and UR Bengal?
Thank you very much! ^^

[Maddy]

This wasn't fair, was it?

Demand wise, definitely unfair to the zonkey.

Unfair to the buckskin pps, which is worth relatively around 3 09 rare/VRs.

[JJdiner]

This?

thank you!

[sɪᴍᴘʟɪᴄɪᴛʏ]

Hello~
Link
What would need to be added to fill the gap between the Wolf PPS and UR Bengal?
Thank you very much! ^^

[Maddy]

offer 1

would this be fair to me? should I edit the trade at all?

offer 2

got another offer. also said they could offer their green toxic.

offer 3

yet another offer! said they would also offer their peach

First one: Joker is worth 755C$, the angel advent is worth around 280-300C$. So technically they're overpaying with the C$ and angel advent alone. Will edit with the rest momentarily.

Second: unfair to joker unless they offer their toxic, but I think the toxic would make it unfair to them.

Third: Heavy overpay for the joker, as the cucumber is above the big gap and the joker is not.

[The Plague.]

How about this? <3 Thanks to anyone who answers, it mean a whole lot!

[Croccultist]

Hows this?

Unfair to the pinata from what ive seen, but I wanted a second opinion.

[Maddy]

Hows this?

Unfair to the pinata from what ive seen, but I wanted a second opinion.

unfair to pinata. It's worth a 2012 uncommon pet. You've got one 2012 common, ish, if you squish their offer together.