The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Bubbled Aurora]

Is this fair? demand wise

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kA3xw0U43g

[♥Sterek♥]

Hello there ^.^
Do you think this would be a fair trade, please? c:
Thanks in advance ♥

I think a Cerberus swap would be fair in and of itself but I would get a second opinion.

Second opinion anyone, please? c:

Im not sure what the orange cerb is going for, but I know for sure that it goes for a lot more than the red cerb, so I disagree with that it would be a fair swap. This is also the case because the orange one is a lot rarer nd a year older store pet, its way harder to find than the red one ^^

[Nicnova]

Id say unfair to them, I dont have the time rn to go through the worth of every single item on your side, but to be frank all I saw where 2011 items and up. Seeing as most items/sets obtained in for example 2011 will be worth max a 2011 uncommon, Except for like maybe some high demand items as the ravens could probably go for a rare from the year they were released for example. Because adding all this up it would probably end up to a bunch of commons and uncommons on your side from 2011- 2017 while their side is offering 09 rares and very rares. If you wanna calculate it all out Id say to use this thread; viewtopic.php?f=20&t=212787

And just use the search function to search for the items ^^

Thank you very much!

[Bearbs]

Somebody, i'd like to edit fast (:
What is a fair price in C$ for my bunnies?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Df0HDYkGvw

[theupsidedown]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=735027

this group is for the 2008 tier 7 heart dog, is this fair?

also ive been told different opinions, ive heard under, ive heard my last offer was over, and ive heard its fine so please please help me

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=69791349 << this was my last offer

[beastly.]

Hello there ^.^
Do you think this would be a fair trade, please? c:
Thanks in advance ♥

I think a Cerberus swap would be fair in and of itself but I would get a second opinion.

Second opinion anyone, please? c:

false, the orange cerebus is on the main list whereas the red cerebus is on the september list. it's still massive overpay on your side though since the dogtag alone would be overpay as it is above the orange cerb on the mainlist, above the gap whereas the orange cerb is below it. i'm not sure how demand is between the cerb and the dogtag but by rarity alone, the dogtag is well overpay, the rest is just even more severe overpay. very unfair to you.

[Constellation.]

This? I know the GWJ is above the U-Nick-orn but with demand? This is the second U-Nick-orn I've almost straight swapped for a GWJ so was just curious if the demand of both is equal or if I got lucky twice haha.

[The Fifth Spirit]

UR Aussie for a Joker dog, I know it’s more than fair rarity-wise, how about demand-wise?

UR Aussies aren't as much in demand right now as Jokers are from what I've noticed in the forums and can be hard to trade off with that case.

What could one compare the value of an Aussie to, then, in this instance? As in, what else could they put in exhxnade for the Joker that would roughly equal the Aussie’s value taking in rarity and demand currently?

[beastly.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69825519&userid=910072&signature=tGnlRL_2IeADpa57NpF56g

thank you for the previous response! i have edited the trade and wonder if this would be considered fair now or if it is still too far under. thank you for all who have helped!

Unfair to you, Flowerpot is worth more then dragon.

thank you! second opinions? even though the flowerpot is worth more, i am looking at demand quite a bit so i would love to know if it would be fair that way or still not.

edit: they removed the september list malk dragon as well and added 20 C$. help is much appreciated!

[Constellation.]

Hello there ^.^
Do you think this would be a fair trade, please? c:
Thanks in advance ♥

I think a Cerberus swap would be fair in and of itself but I would get a second opinion.

Second opinion anyone, please? c:

false, the orange cerebus is on the main list whereas the red cerebus is on the september list. it's still massive overpay on your side though since the dogtag alone would be overpay as it is above the orange cerb on the mainlist. i'm not sure how demand is between the cerb and the dogtag but by rarity alone, the dogtag is well overpay, the rest is just even more severe overpay. very unfair to you.

I've had both cerberuses recently so I'll bite. If you're looking for list value go by that of course, but demand wise most people value the red cerberus at 2 nons and the orange cerberus between 4-6 nons, so somewhere on that spectrum if that helps. (: