The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jade,]

Was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Dw-oI5DHKQ
Thank you so very much, the ur peach was a dreamie so i was probably gonna accept either way, but some advice is appreciated too!

Please help!

[keettweet]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance for any replies!

[Bubbled Aurora]

can someone help me i first offered a september lepoard

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tTqsdgZCyw

also this

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8cME6QcbFA

[vencrypt]

Could someone tell if this would be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BsFmxEIKTA

Thanks in advance

Very unfair to the blue ice rat, it is a September list.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69824636&userid=910072&signature=OyUcODbVoxuDwdYUTL-5zQ

i know this is technically under due to the flowerpots worth but since it has terrible demand, would this be fair? i know the blue rose dog has great demand typically.

Although it has terrible demand, it is till very unfair to the flowerpot.

can someone help me i first offered a september lepoard

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tTqsdgZCyw

also this

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8cME6QcbFA

I'd say unfair to the warrior cats demand wise as they can fetch multiple '09 rares for each cat. Though, it is slightly overpay rarity wise. Though I think the leopard would be too much overpay.
The second is overpay as well, though it depends on how much people value the warrior cats as of now.

Is this fair?

Help please c;[/quote]

Very unfair to them, the overall total is worth well over $100

Is this fair? Thanks in advance for any replies!

Unfair to the other person, the items were just released this or last year (I think?)

[Kitsuneyokai]

Is this fair?

Second opinion please c;

[Nira.]

Hello there ^.^
Do you think this would be a fair trade, please? c:
Thanks in advance ♥

[Dumbdolphin]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69822683&userid=862451&signature=0ruolApHlCAN8B80Omkvkw

I'm tempted to accept this trade, is the fox demand going down though?

it depends on how you value the Fox and the Zonkey; I believe the Zonkey will be placed at around 2 nons of worth, and the fox is being valued at 1-2 of them depending on the user. Their demand is still apparently greater than the UR peas.
The marionette dog's demand is also something...
I'd say that's a good deal for both sides; it depends on how you personally value the URs and the marionette's demand as well ^^
you might need second opinions as I'm not sure of the exact value the marionette can go for.

Thanks! Any second opinions?

[SilverCervine]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance for any replies!

the turtle is from 2012, all the other items from 2017 - so the other person is slightly overpaying

[The Fifth Spirit]

UR Aussie for a Joker dog, I know it’s more than fair rarity-wise, how about demand-wise?

[Crocodillian]

Was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Dw-oI5DHKQ
Thank you so very much, the ur peach was a dreamie so i was probably gonna accept either way, but some advice is appreciated too!

Please help!

The Phoenix adds up to 1 non and a sorbet so valuing the Peach at one non makes that trade perfectly fair ^^
The Peach will probably be placed around that; so i'd say it was a good trade!