The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[Legacyy]

What would they have to add?
XXX

from my point of view their under by 27 (as i said before [grinner:15 '09 rares, cheshire 7 '09 rares, store pet 1 '09 rares]) so if we went by mid advents their under by approx 3.5 mid advents give or take

[minoosh]

What would they have to add?
XXX

from my point of view their under by 27 (as i said before [grinner:15 '09 rares, cheshire 7 '09 rares, store pet 1 '09 rares]) so if we went by mid advents their under by approx 3.5 mid advents give or take

Oooooo Ok thank you very much (once again) :D

[Legacyy]

What would they have to add?
XXX

from my point of view their under by 27 (as i said before [grinner:15 '09 rares, cheshire 7 '09 rares, store pet 1 '09 rares]) so if we went by mid advents their under by approx 3.5 mid advents give or take

Oooooo Ok thank you very much (once again)

second opinoin for this very nice person ?

[Shadow2204]

this ,, ?

thank you ,,

Unfair.
The BMD goes for balloon dogs and they're offering up to (if the september dog grows to the highest value one) 6 mid advents + a low advent. (The BMD is worth 5 mid advents rarity wise)

[Charizard !]

we're both unsure, what would need to be changed(if it's not fair)?

on the other side, I know its not fair how many '09 rares or mid advents would need to be added :)

[Lady Sif]

we're both unsure, what would need to be changed(if it's not fair)?

The trade is unfair to them. Either they should remove the grinner and you add about 2 mid-advents or they remove the malk dragon and then they add 3-4 mid advents.

this ,, ?

thank you ,,

Not unfair to you by rarity, but given demand I would not recommend the trade.

[boston]

ur peas for eat me demand wise?
thanks in advance.

[Charizard !]

we're both unsure, what would need to be changed(if it's not fair)?

The trade is unfair to them. Either they should remove the grinner and you add about 2 mid-advents or they remove the malk dragon and then they add 3-4 mid advents.

Thank you!! any other opinions before I edit?

[.Animal.]

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69709202&userid=906333&signature=6VqepmdwPeZ9Hww3oXJKZA

Thank you in advance:]

[zing]

we're both unsure, what would need to be changed(if it's not fair)?

The trade is unfair to them. Either they should remove the grinner and you add about 2 mid-advents or they remove the malk dragon and then they add 3-4 mid advents.

Thank you!! any other opinions before I edit?

demand-wise and rarity-wise they're over.
demand-wise being due to the malk dragon having more demand over the september list,
but the grinner is a bit hard to trade off. ^^

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69709202&userid=906333&signature=6VqepmdwPeZ9Hww3oXJKZA

Thank you in advance:]

yeah that's actually quite fine, it violates the 3 month rule by one month but since they added the uncommon i'm thinking it's a fair trade. :")