The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[shelter.]

thoughts?
note: a bit bulky
i don't really wanna do such a massive trade-down, but wanted to ask nonetheless

--

also, this one?
i'm quite clingy about warriors, but idk this seems like a good one?

--

aand finally this
i know elementals are in demand, but i've been seeking the sitting cat for a while now..

thanks to anyone responding <3

[Pluto.]

this is a bid for my 20k gems on fr, how should I rate this?

xxx
rating is right here:
Deciding
Unfair,
AMAZING
This is good
I should Auto this!
Autoed!

their side is worth about 10k, I'd rate it at "Amazing/this is good"

thank you!

[Radioactive Wolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69663741&userid=373509&signature=ENS8BF71jNoNCfMtmayY5g

Would this be fair both rarity and demand wise? It took me a while to get a quantity of list pets so I'm a little reluctant to part with it and both of my BAs. Should I accept it because I know I'd be parting with a few high demand pets?

Any help please? ^^

[GhostPants]

How does this look demand wise? Any help is appreciated!
@Gasoline

EDIT:
blue Ice rat x2 + Lime ice rat= ??? (sorry if this is the wrong thread for questions like this ;u;)
I know rats have bad demand but whats the most i could get?

EDIT X2: How much are UR bengals going for? ;u;'
(Thank you those who answered!)

[korok]

Hello, is this fair? If not, what should be edited?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... V8Q1WGmBOQ

And is a GWJ for a Raven Dog fair demand wise?

I'll try my best. :3

So July PPS = 2 nons

Zebra can only get about 1 non, maybe 1.5 if you get really lucky, because zebras have bad demand.

0.5 a non = 1.5 sorbets, 0.5 a sorbet is about red toxic tier, and the other pets of yours don't add to 1 sorbet. :3 So unfair to them

Ravens also tend to go for a non, a GWJ would be overpay. :3

[WilsonHiggsbury]

thoughts?
note: a bit bulky
i don't really wanna do such a massive trade-down, but wanted to ask nonetheless

--

also, this one?
i'm quite clingy about warriors, but idk this seems like a good one?

--

aand finally this
i know elementals are in demand, but i've been seeking the sitting cat for a while now..

thanks to anyone responding <3

not sure about the first one.

the 2nd one seems like good overpay for your 2009 uncommon, especially since lions are also kinda high in demand. I'd personally take this.

the 3rd one, the 2009 very rare cat is overpay for your 2009/10 rare. Demand wise? I've seen malk cats go for more, personally. But if you've been searching for this specific cat for a while, i'd considor taking it.

[prettykittythekitten]

Is this fair? Involves a Sept. '09 rare!

[GhostPants]

How does this look demand wise? Any help is appreciated!
@Gasoline

EDIT:
blue Ice rat x2 + Lime ice rat= ??? (sorry if this is the wrong thread for questions like this ;u;)
I know rats have bad demand but whats the most i could get?

EDIT X2: How much are UR bengals going for? ;u;'
(Thank you those who answered!)

[Radioactive Wolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vFhSA0FdJA

Would this be fair both rarity and demand wise? It took me a while to get a quantity of list pets so I'm a little reluctant to part with it and both of my BAs. Should I accept it because I know I'd be parting with a few high demand pets?

Any help please? ^^

[WilsonHiggsbury]

Is this fair? Involves a Sept. '09 rare!

No. This is not fair to the 2009 rare, their side is worth 1/2 2014 rares at max.