The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[TheUnknown]

Please help..

[Rukari]

is this fair at all? i do really want the pets they're offering, but the years are quite different for the bunnies at least... i've been back on CS for about a year but haven't done much trading so i'm still extremely uncertain about value

Wrong link hun

[TheFabHawk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69438974&userid=781126&signature=dhqYHdBXZfGpHB0hTPmgKg


Is this fair?

from what I can tell, yours is
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/archive/2008/August/Dog
on here. from august 2008 and will end up being very rare. that it's from 2008 also makes it very valuable.

the one offered is from september 2008 and also very rare. (though I dunno if that one is the one that has one more growth stage or not, it might).
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/archive/ ... tember/Dog

I guess it would come down to which one you would like more
(notw. I'm relatively new and others more experienced might give you a slightly different answer but that's what I can gauge)

EDIT!
Sorry! I see I was a bit hasty in me answer. it says it PPS so it won't grow more.
the date(name?) on the pet offered says 2010 . but as you can see in the link it is from 2008 not 2010

[Crystal_Winterz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69439149&userid=851919&signature=BN7yDVqFyYRpko68TtYJ3g
Is this fair? Ehat makes it fair?

I think it's fair, check with someone else just in case

[Peppermint mist]

was this a fair trade? Thanks in advance!

a Sorbet is worth a gearback + dark leopard, im not exactly sure what the pets except for the gearback on your side add up to but it looks very fair

Thank you! Could I possibly get a second opinion?

[Beautiful disaster ♡]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QT2H8O33Qw
Wich side is over?

[Ꭺlina]

practically drooling over this trade :') demand wise ?

This seems fair! The dragons all have high demand uvu

Yes, but the zonkey can go anywhere from 1.5 nons to 2 nons, so I wouldn’t accept.

could i get another opinion ?[/quote]

very unfair to you, their side, even with demand isn’t even worth half a non (actually their side isnt even worth a Sorbet and a non = 3 sorbets )and the Zonkey goes for 1-2 nons right now

[hihibash93]

is this fair at all? i do really want the pets they're offering, but the years are quite different for the bunnies at least... i've been back on CS for about a year but haven't done much trading so i'm still extremely uncertain about value

Wrong link hun

whoops! does this work?

[ruthless]

Which bid is the best for my UR Cinnabun?

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

Personally, I would go for the one with the non, cake dog and advent as the cinnabun(I believe) goes for a non so this is overpay. The fox is also worth a non but the other trade has a september list and advent list.
The ones with the fruit are okay but fruit pets have bad demand. Same goes for the one with the line tribal and rose dog. Tribals have bad demand. The other trades, I'd I remember correctly, are quite unfair.
The one with the C$ and rat may be(?) Overpay but not a lot of people like C$ for lists and rats have bad demand.

Please get a second opinion if you like, I'm not too good at this but just helping out as much as I can (:

Anyone else?

[Lilo.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69439065&userid=821239&signature=FmxjNatcgBQ5ihXpQytqqA

Anyone known if this is fair?