The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[PenguinQueen]

Whats the deal up with this one? I know rats have terrible demand but idk

Lol I'm kinda the one who sent you the trade so probably don't wanna hear from me, so feel free to get a second opinion if you like ^^
A '10 rare = 2 '11 rares, and no matter how you value the rare in UCs (2 - 4), it's unfair for the rat. Valuing at 2 UCs makes a '10 rare worth 4 '11 UCs and there's only 3 on your side, and if at 4 that's 8 '11 UCs. Demand depends on how much you value the rat

This looks unfair to the rat. A rare is worth 4 uncommon pets of its year, so the uncommon side doesn't add up to a 2011 rare, much less a 2010 rare. Even with rats not being very popular, it's unfair to the rat.

[Romeo Montagu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.phpid=69175222&userid=908570&signature=mWrWBVSLWCAyTt_i6cpmbg

Is this fair?

Wrong link. Please use the [share trade] one ^^

Oops sorry,
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Tt_i6cpmbg

[fawnive]

I need an opinion for this!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tkHVu7bAaQ

[Pom d'Apee]

hello c:
can anyone tell me if this trade is fair please ? '-'
edit : and how is this one ?
thank you in advance ♥

[WesternWolf2528]

I need an opinion for this!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tkHVu7bAaQ

Unfair for you. The UC for UC is fair (the lions demand would make up for the months gap) but a '16 rare for a '14 rare isn't unfair.

[Galaxyofstarss]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fj0ZczUWKg

Taking rarity and demand into consideration?

[malluvsduckies]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69180890&userid=824007&signature=zzSfuryiPKVte0t4nZVDQw

Is this fair for me?

[Pom d'Apee]

hello c:
can anyone tell me if this trade is fair please ? '-'
edit : and how is this one ?
thank you in advance ♥

#1.) unfair to you — if i remember correctly the ur bee gos for around 2-3 nons, while there offering 1 + a GWJ + some rares and such, witch don’t fill the gap.

#2.) the bee is worth about 1390 c$, so this is still unfair to you even with the advent added.
also, c$ is harder to trade off when it comes to list pets.

personally i’d wait and see if you could get a better offer.

hope this helped! (:

okay thank you for your answer ♥
can i have another opinion please ?

[Lunameyza]

Hi! Is this fair? If not, what should be changed on their side?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _Tm1isvRnQ

[Romeo Montagu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Tt_i6cpmbg

Is this fair?