The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Vanta22exual]

Is this fair? If not, what would need to be added to make it fair?

[Little Flame]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LlC7PS5Sig
Thank you in advance^^

[veggie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69156581&userid=700894&signature=-QyWAkqtB-cLLlC7PS5Sig
Thank you in advance^^

Even if the white pup turns out to be a rare (which more than likely isn't going to happen anyway because he was a free adopt), this would still be unfair to you due to the age gap.

[Little Flame]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69156581&userid=700894&signature=-QyWAkqtB-cLLlC7PS5Sig
Thank you in advance^^

Even if the white pup turns out to be a rare (which more than likely isn't going to happen anyway because he was a free adopt), this would still be unfair to you due to the age gap.

Thank you!

[stan.]

Would this trade be fair for their nonballoon? I value the store pets as an '09 rare each, though I know they are generally valued lower on this thread.

Thanks in advance for any help! :)

They aren't 'valued lower here', you are severely overvaluing them.
Short answer, no, it's not fair to them. Even if you overvalue your pets.
The list pets on your side (Floppy Eared September + Emerald B-wolf) plus the three 2009's very rares (Joker Bun, the pink pps and leopard rat) add up around to a Red X Tier.

The fifteen store pets add 7 09's rares, and bumps the worth to a Blue Ice Rat tier.
However, if you insist in overvaluing them, the worth could get to the Dark Leopard tier.

The Non-Balloon is worth a Red Rose and a Line Tribal, the Dark Leopard covers the Red Rose's worth but it just doesn't adds up.

Get a second opinion, I tried to make my calculations accurate but I may have screwed it up somewhere.

Edit: Yeah, I had the feeling the Joker Bun was a list but I looked for it on the Advent and September. My mistake. Get more opinions.

[musicgurl333]

Would this trade be fair for their nonballoon? I value the store pets as an '09 rare each, though I know they are generally valued lower on this thread.

Thanks in advance for any help!

They aren't 'valued lower here', you are severely overvaluing them.

Short answer, no, it's not fair to them. Even if you overvalue your pets.
The list pets on your side (Floppy Eared September + Emerald B-wolf) plus the three 2009's very rares (Joker Bun, the pink pps and leopard rat) add up around to a Red X Tier.

The fifteen store pets add 7 09's rares, and bumps the worth to a Blue Ice Rat tier.
However, if you insist in overvaluing them, the worth could get to the Dark Leopard tier.

The Non-Balloon is worth a Red Rose and a Line Tribal, the Dark Leopard covers the Red Rose's worth but it just doesn't adds up.

Get a second opinion, I tried to make my calculations accurate but I may have screwed it up somewhere.

Actually the joker bun is also a list pet, and only a tier below their pet. As for overvaluing the store pets, there's not an official value, and I've never traded one for less than an '09 rare (and I offer the same) so that's why I value them that way.

Could I get a second opinion? Thanks again for any help!

[tsukimis_hope✩]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h_jwghl9Ng

[squail]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=69161658

Wrong link

[musicgurl333]

Would this trade be fair for their nonballoon? I value the store pets as an '09 rare each, though I know they are generally valued lower on this thread.

Thanks in advance for any help!

[Huskyflower]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66069068&userid=21889&signature=dj5nka3TE0BRwTP0FQvbag

I already accepted it but I'm just curious lol... was this a fair trade for my raven dog and patchwork dog?