The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[doggo]

hello! I am holding an auction for my raven dog, and it has come down to these bids. Which one should I accept and why? c: thank you all so much for your help! <3

Bid One

Bid Two

Bid Three

Bid Four

Bid Five

Bid Six

[crucifying.]

Screeches, would a lovely person tell me if this was fair? The trade's already complete but I'm concerned. It was supposed to be an auction bid but the person hastily accepted saying "This is fine thank you" and I'm suspecting that it was unfair for me because of how quickly they responded. Thank you for your help! :)

Usually a store pets goes for a 2010 late rare, so yes you overpayed

agreed, especially considering the sitting cats generally have high demand.

[bbqkiwi]

Heya! Is this fair to me? Need some advice

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ulZcXzm3bA

[phayraoh]

Is this fair?

There are:
- Tier 5 cream Santa hat
- 1 ‘09 common
- 2 ‘10 rares
- 4 ‘10 uncommons
- 7 ‘11 uncommons
- 4 ‘12 commons
- 6 ‘12 uncommons
- 1 ‘13 common
- 2 ‘13 uncommons
- 5 ‘14 uncommons
- 2 ‘15 uncommons
- 5 C$

[Easterrabbit2]

Heya! Is this fair to me? Need some advice

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ulZcXzm3bA

Unfair to them . The total would be about 21-26 C $ Or more depending on what you value uncommons and the unknown rarities.

[cerulean blue]

x
-accepted this a long time ago, but was this acutually fair or overpay/underpay?
x
same thing with this one^

[JJdiner]

this

hey guys! would you help me out with this? is this fair with demand?

[bbqkiwi]

Heya! Is this fair to me? Need some advice

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ulZcXzm3bA

Unfair to them . The total would be about 21-26 C $ Or more depending on what you value uncommons and the unknown rarities.

I figured I would owe them a bit more (that I don't have), but since they aren't communicating with me on their wants, I decided to cancel. Thank you for your advice

[kjzq]

Is this fair?

There are:
- Tier 5 cream Santa hat
- 1 ‘09 common
- 2 ‘10 rares
- 4 ‘10 uncommons
- 7 ‘11 uncommons
- 4 ‘12 commons
- 6 ‘12 uncommons
- 1 ‘13 common
- 2 ‘13 uncommons
- 5 ‘14 uncommons
- 2 ‘15 uncommons
- 5 C$

if my math isn't off, the uncommons/rares on the quantity side is worth roughly 2-3 09 rares . the gap between the cookie dog and the cream hat is 1-2 09 rares, so they're overpaying . i'd recommend getting another opinion just in case .

[OHHAILTHECHOOKOFLIFE]

Would you personally accept this trade c:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69102452&userid=862310&signature=eIQLOWFeARY6qf-ql3zA8w


Thank you for any/all replies

looking for third opinions c: Thank you for the responses