The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69052274&userid=834615&signature=GZjjGsgH_19K6Y_fO2LnqA

I am pretty sure this is not fair but could someone help please!

Yup, their side is only worth a '14 uncommon (:
Your cat is worth a '12 rare, not '16

[kyum-]

i know '14 store pets are worth a late '09 rare rarity-wise, but does this pet have demand that makes it worth 2 '09 rares?

[fawnive]

Thanks for the advices y'all!

[Ancient Wind]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69052274&userid=834615&signature=GZjjGsgH_19K6Y_fO2LnqA

I am pretty sure this is not fair but could someone help please!

Yup, their side is only worth a '14 uncommon (:
Your cat is worth a '12 rare, not '16

Thank you so much!

[~Cookies And Milk~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ot9GCOAGQA Could someone plz help me on this

[Charizard !]

is this alright? Thank you for any response!

[Guest]

Is this fair?

I need an answer!

Its overpay, if you use it as two '16 rares = a '17 very rare, so you would be overpaying

disagree. '17 store pets are worth a late '10 rare each. so it is, in fact, unfair to the griffin.
the other side of the griffin is paying equivalent to a '15 very rare, '15 rare and '15 uncommon, which makes it a large underpay on their side.

after re-reading my 'very rare' statement (and editing a ton of times due to coding cries), i decided i needed to cut it down to rares-
15vr = 2 15r = 1 14r

I agree with kyum-, tye gryphon is a store pet worth a 2010 rare, their side is overpaying

[dear.chaton]

I know both pets go for overpay
but with this trade, how fair is it
to me? What would they need to
add to make it fair? Thank you^^

[Charizard !]

is this alright? Thank you for any response!

[Sakine]

Hello, it this a fair trade?

Thanks in advance!