The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[fallen;]

Hey there! Is this trade fair? They sent it to me and I'm not very good with item trades.

Thank you!

[Zombilon]

I'v been here for a while, but haven't until recently gotten into trading pets. I was wondering if this trade is worth it? I'm not the best when it comes to valuing past event pets;;

Boop

Their 2011 uncommon alone is overpay for your side due to the date differences. ^^

[sienna77]

I haven't been on in a few years so i've forgotten a lot about trading e-e

c:

Your pet is a grown white scarf dog (advent list tier 1) worth three to four 2009 rares. The top adds up to about two 2009 rares + 2014 rare + two 2014 uncommons. Unfair to you. ^^

I disagree, it's unfair to them yes, but I don't think their side adds up to more than two '09 rares, each of the 2017 store pets is only worth a '10 rare, and even if two '10 rares equals one '09 rare, the other pets don't add up to much more than a early '14-late '13 rare in my opinion, so equaling a total of 1 '09 rare and 1 '13-14 rare.

I'v been here for a while, but haven't until recently gotten into trading pets. I was wondering if this trade is worth it? I'm not the best when it comes to valuing past event pets;;

Boop

they are overpaying, a '11 uncommon is worth more than a '14 and a '15 uncommon, but you'll have to get another opinion on what else would need to be added.

[Aviator06]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EjilZE71LA

Is this fair? Just double checking. I thought it was okay, but just in case.

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68572936&userid=619341&signature=BXT4AR7Eb8jgEjilZE71LA

Is this fair? Just double checking. I thought it was okay, but just in case.

All the pets in the trade were extended into August 09 and thus worth a mid-late 09 rare each. The trade was pretty much fair

[Rinsea]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68572936&userid=619341&signature=BXT4AR7Eb8jgEjilZE71LA

Is this fair? Just double checking. I thought it was okay, but just in case.

fair rarity wise but the pups on their side have a higher demand than the purple dogs on yours

[Aviator06]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TVZ4f7weoA

Is this fair? Also, thanks to everyone who has been responding :'D I'm not trying to spam or anything I just like to trade and don't want to accidentally scam anyone.

[Castiel~Angel]

Are either of these fair to me?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -sln3iHYNA
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ILNn0keYPw
Thanks in advance, also these trades are for my on going auction

[fallen;]

Hey there! Is this trade fair? They sent it to me and I'm not very good with item trades.

Thank you!

[rookie rook]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68572090&userid=823491&signature=C_5gizXZ8pqgJQ9gWXkYzQ

Fair?

No, they are worth about a 09 rare each if I am correct,

Thank you! Second opinion?

And how about this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l1DP0EDN8w

A 2014 store pet is worth a late 2009 rare. A 2016 is worth a mid 2010 rare. The first trade is unfair.

The second trade is definitely unfair, no pets add up to a 2009 rare. At most, they add up to a 2011 rare with a 2010 uncommon, but even then that's not close to enough (and that estimate is wrong).