The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Steve Harrington]

OK. I have a couple of trades and I would like two know which side is fair and which isn't. I want as many opinions as possible!

First - x

Second - xx (In the message they stated the rat isn't the true date)

1. Unfair to you. Your cat is a "warrior cat" which has quite some demand. Rarity wise it is unfair to them.
2. What they mean is that it is a rereleased rat I personally wouldn't take it because rats tend to not have the greatest demand. The zodiac dog you could get more than 1 '09 rare for.

Thank you! Second opinions?:D

[BioDumbnition]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68377579&userid=795787&signature=3k51OFI-rDMGSgujy28Urw

Is this fair??

Fair??

Not really...

Can you be more specific??

[depressedanonymous,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68382066&userid=652611&signature=B-vd-Ggqg8J569B0cxiheQ

Is this fair? If not, by how much and who needs to add what?
- Collector

[GoldenSlumbers]

xXx

Is this fair if not what should change please help

[♥seokjin♥]

is this trade fair, rarity and demand wise?
i'd prefer if i was somehow able to remove the cake dog for something else, and i have pets in this group:
here
thanks in advance! ^^

[Corey Taylor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 83dZZWyfAg

Is this one fair?

[lucky333123]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68377579&userid=795787&signature=3k51OFI-rDMGSgujy28Urw

Is this fair??

Fair??

Not really...

Can you be more specific??[/quote]
The C$ is worth about a target dog tier. Demand wise each zodiac tends to go for at least an '09 rare, but since this is the whole set, I can see the whole set going for more. Because of this, I would say it is unfair to them, but it really depends on how they value the whole set.

Rarity wise, you will be overpaying.

[GoldenSlumbers]

xXx

Is this fair if not what should change please help

[depressedanonymous,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68382066&userid=652611&signature=B-vd-Ggqg8J569B0cxiheQ

Is this fair? If not, by how much and who needs to add what?
- Collector

[♥seokjin♥]

is this trade fair, rarity and demand wise?
i'd prefer if i was somehow able to remove the cake dog for something else, and i have pets in this group:
here
thanks in advance! ^^