The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[soupy.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67862195&userid=814854&signature=Meg7X1NEgp_idq1t8JIBpw
Oof, not sure if this is fair or not. I'm not good with rare+ trades :P
What would you guys say?

[NineTail]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67859816&userid=903789&signature=2ZVcj6tx3606Tkm4bnfVUA

I think this is overpay, but I'm never sure

Yes, this is an overpay. They overpayed, but considering how people like the new halloween pets, i think it is ok. But they are definitely overpaying. Your opinion is needed for this. I hope i gave you an answer. Hope this helped!~

[Winter526]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Tkm4bnfVUA

I think this is overpay, but I'm never sure

Yes, this is an overpay. They overpayed, but considering how people like the new halloween pets, i think it is ok. But they are definitely overpaying. Your opinion is needed for this. I hope i gave you an answer. Hope this helped!~

Thank you so much, it definitely helped

[Little Flame]

Would this be fair?
Thanks in advance💕
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I1jF9Im0YA

[Pepperikorn]

Hi, is this fair? Thank you for any replies :)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sXgIG08tQQ

[Mythz]

Hello~
Is this fair?

Thanks for any help!

[ThunderCedar]

Hello~
Is this fair?

Thanks for any help!

I'd say your things are too recent
They should be worth a pinch less than 1 c$ each
This is unfair to them

Hi, is this fair? Thank you for any replies
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sXgIG08tQQ

Extremely unfair to you due to dates

[Mythz]

Hello~
Is this fair?

Thanks for any help!

I'd say your things are too recent
They should be worth a pinch less than 1 c$ each
This is unfair to them

Okay, thank you!
What about demand wise? I know halloween pets are quite popular right now! ^^

[NineTail]

Hi, is this fair? Thank you for any replies
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sXgIG08tQQ

You are definitely overpaying because you have the 2012 rare caterpillar.

Would this be fair?
Thanks in advance💕
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I1jF9Im0YA

Unfair for you. Three 2010 cats worth more than just 2 2016 rares and some commons.

Hello~
Is this fair?

Thanks for any help!

I would say this is a bit unfair for them since recent halloween pets that are for free and a free item don't really worth 3 $CS. You can get them for free, so their demand isn't that high either.


Hope this helped!

[ThunderCedar]

Hello~
Is this fair?

Thanks for any help!

I'd say your things are too recent
They should be worth a pinch less than 1 c$ each
This is unfair to them

Okay, thank you!
What about demand wise? I know halloween pets are quite popular right now! ^^

They're all free adopts, I've honestly not noticed that much demand for them. Just got a trade with some EPPS lions and they offered them to me fairly, they asked for 2 commons for both.