The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[.holliday]

Would a blue toxic and a BEG be fair for a UR phoenix? I haven’t been on in a while and i don’t remember the demand of certain pets

[the]

Is this Fair? I'm really tempted because I've been searching like a maniac to complete staff collections.

A moonswirl is worth 4 Nons, which is worth way over 1000 '09 rares, therefore e x t r e a m l y unfair to you

it isn't a moonswirl. they offer list pets and high demand pets so this isn't that unfair..
however, their side wouldn't be enough for one non and the dogtag is worth 3 nons, so it's still unfair to you

[lucẏ]

this?

pretty sure its fair, if anything they're overpaying but just making sure

[the]

this?

pretty sure its fair, if anything they're overpaying but just making sure

yeah, it's fair. your side is worth 4 rares '09 and the bumblebee spider is worth 3-4 rares '09

[dia_dartenheit]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NYPGnW94ww
is it fair?

[Tanetane]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67382878&userid=348410&signature=yBAqxw9uieVK7JgaKWEgaw
Can I get an opinion on this trade?

[squail]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67382878&userid=348410&signature=yBAqxw9uieVK7JgaKWEgaw
Can I get an opinion on this trade?

Very unfair to the owner of the rat

[.holliday]

Would a blue toxic and a BEG be fair for a UR phoenix? I haven’t been on in a while and i don’t remember the demand of certain pets

[Kyles]

What do you guys think of This?

[Horror]

An auction I held just ended and I was wondering which of the bids were the best for my sitting cats. Any advice and insisted are appreciated and thank you in advance!

- 1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4tHWeNDLNQ

- 2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... e41B6CqMsQ

- 3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TYvvu-RIcg

- 4. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sM33H0I8Zg

- 5. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lelniCL3rQ

- 6. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4lnBwBTcNg

- 7. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uDL0-9et3g

3, 6 or 7 are my top three! The rest of the trades seem like you're overpaying a lot.

Thank you!! Any second opinions? (Sixth and fifth bids canceled)

1. Unfair to you rarity wise as their side is only worth 1.5 09 rares
2. Unfair to you. Their store pet set can swap for 2 late 09 rares, but the other pets hardly add up to even 2 uncommon warriors
3. Their two store pets = 1 christmas sitting cat
All the other pets on your side add up to 130-172C$ so it's unfair to you
4. Unfair to you by an eraly 09 rare + early 2010 rare
5. Their side is hardly worth 2 of your uncommon warriors so it's unfair to you
6. Their 2 late 09 rares = the vr horse
Valuing uncommons @ about 6C$ each = 54C$, so the C$ more or less covers them
Everything else is quite a bit of overpay for the rare warrior.
So the trade is unfair to them by a little under 3 09 rares
7. Fish = rare warrior + 4 uncommon warriors
Easter 2010 bun = 4 uncommon warriors
Easter 2012 rare = last uncommon
They're overpaying by a bit under 10 09 rares

7 is the most overpay, followed by 6. All the others are unfair to you just by worth alone

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67382878&userid=348410&signature=yBAqxw9uieVK7JgaKWEgaw
Can I get an opinion on this trade?

Unfair to you by a late 09 rare + late 2010 rare