The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[KyokoCinnamon]

My Sunjewel + Dog Tag = UR Tiger??

I kinda need to know too for future reference..

[최종호]

So currently Im holding an auction for my joker dog.
I know that the Zebra is a huge overtrade, but I kind of want quantity...
So If I could trouble someone, which is the best trade for me?

1~
2~
3~
4~
5~.

[Foxessunset]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pfuf6cpT3w

Fair?

[watery>~<]

So currently Im holding an auction for my joker dog.
I know that the Zebra is a huge overtrade, but I kind of want quantity...
So If I could trouble someone, which is the best trade for me?

1~
2~
3~
4~
5~.

I personally value the Joker Dog at 1 non
I would accept trade 5 because its the one worth the most here's why:
1. Non + BMD is worth about a non and a balloon dog, decent overpay
2. All the items and BEG and lists and C$ is also nice and decent overpay but it proabaly adds up to an Aussie or a little under
3. I value all zebras at only a non because of their bad demand so its probably the one that goes for the lease or 2nd least
4. I value the Cinnabun at a non-1.5 nons also decent overpay
5. A UR aussie alone would proabaly be worth the most of all bids, but a Growing white july, line tribal and all those items?! That would be overpay and their side is worth about 2-2.5 ish nons cuz the growing white july doesnt have the best demand, but still!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67298109&userid=811324&signature=HSRyvRpaeeSwpfuf6cpT3w

Fair?

Very unfair to you
Forst of all, their nick pet has bad demand. Also, their side is only worth 1 2010 uncommon + a 2011 uncommon while your side has 5 2010 uncommons. 2 of their 2011 uncommons would be a fair swap for 1 of your 2010 uncommons. 2 2011 uncommons = 1 2010 uncommon

[tenor the rat god]

me:
1)
ur zonkey + sunjewel + ? = ur tiger

2)
ur zonkey = ur cinnabon

thanks so much<3

KyokoCinnamon :
1) I personally value the sunjewel at 5 non and zebra at 1 and tiger at 8 so you would have to add 1 more non

2) I value them both at 1 non so its seems fair to me

watery>~< :
Overall I agree but:

1)Some people may value the sunjewel at 4-4.5 nons because most people dont like to trade up

2) I've SEEN the zonkey go for 2 non and the cinnabun for 1.5 at most but I value them both at the same price so its up to you

okay thank you guys. could i have one more opinion for sort of a dealbreaker?

[최종호]

So currently Im holding an auction for my joker dog.
I know that the Zebra is a huge overtrade, but I kind of want quantity...
So If I could trouble someone, which is the best trade for me?

1~
2~
3~
4~
5~.

I personally value the Joker Dog at 1 non
I would accept trade 5 because its the one worth the most here's why:
1. Non + BMD is worth about a non and a balloon dog, decent overpay
2. All the items and BEG and lists and C$ is also nice and decent overpay but it proabaly adds up to an Aussie or a little under
3. I value all zebras at only a non because of their bad demand so its probably the one that goes for the lease or 2nd least
4. I value the Cinnabun at a non-1.5 nons also decent overpay
5. A UR aussie alone would proabaly be worth the most of all bids, but a Growing white july, line tribal and all those items?! That would be overpay and their side is worth about 2-2.5 ish nons cuz the growing white july doesnt have the best demand, but still!

Thank you hon. But may I get a second opinion?
And what exactly is the BEG going for right now?

[tenor the rat god]

me:
1)
ur zonkey + sunjewel + ? = ur tiger

2)
ur zonkey = ur cinnabon

thanks so much<3

KyokoCinnamon :
1) I personally value the sunjewel at 5 non and zebra at 1 and tiger at 8 so you would have to add 1 more non

2) I value them both at 1 non so its seems fair to me

watery>~< :
Overall I agree but:

1)Some people may value the sunjewel at 4-4.5 nons because most people dont like to trade up

2) I've SEEN the zonkey go for 2 non and the cinnabun for 1.5 at most but I value them both at the same price so its up to you

okay thank you guys. could i have one more opinion for sort of a dealbreaker?

[최종호]

So currently Im holding an auction for my joker dog.
I know that the Zebra is a huge overtrade, but I kind of want quantity...
So If I could trouble someone, which is the best trade for me?

1~
2~
3~
4~
5~.

I personally value the Joker Dog at 1 non
I would accept trade 5 because its the one worth the most here's why:
1. Non + BMD is worth about a non and a balloon dog, decent overpay
2. All the items and BEG and lists and C$ is also nice and decent overpay but it proabaly adds up to an Aussie or a little under
3. I value all zebras at only a non because of their bad demand so its probably the one that goes for the lease or 2nd least
4. I value the Cinnabun at a non-1.5 nons also decent overpay
5. A UR aussie alone would proabaly be worth the most of all bids, but a Growing white july, line tribal and all those items?! That would be overpay and their side is worth about 2-2.5 ish nons cuz the growing white july doesnt have the best demand, but still!

Thank you hon. But may I get a second opinion?
And what exactly is the BEG going for right now?

[watery>~<]

So currently Im holding an auction for my joker dog.
I know that the Zebra is a huge overtrade, but I kind of want quantity...
So If I could trouble someone, which is the best trade for me?

1~
2~
3~
4~
5~.

I personally value the Joker Dog at 1 non
I would accept trade 5 because its the one worth the most here's why:
1. Non + BMD is worth about a non and a balloon dog, decent overpay
2. All the items and BEG and lists and C$ is also nice and decent overpay but it proabaly adds up to an Aussie or a little under
3. I value all zebras at only a non because of their bad demand so its probably the one that goes for the lease or 2nd least
4. I value the Cinnabun at a non-1.5 nons also decent overpay
5. A UR aussie alone would proabaly be worth the most of all bids, but a Growing white july, line tribal and all those items?! That would be overpay and their side is worth about 2-2.5 ish nons cuz the growing white july doesnt have the best demand, but still!

Thank you hon. But may I get a second opinion?
And what exactly is the BEG going for right now?

BEG and CEG's are going for a non

[KyokoCinnamon]

So currently Im holding an auction for my joker dog.
I know that the Zebra is a huge overtrade, but I kind of want quantity...
So If I could trouble someone, which is the best trade for me?

1~
2~
3~
4~
5~.

I personally value the Joker Dog at 1 non
I would accept trade 5 because its the one worth the most here's why:
1. Non + BMD is worth about a non and a balloon dog, decent overpay
2. All the items and BEG and lists and C$ is also nice and decent overpay but it proabaly adds up to an Aussie or a little under
3. I value all zebras at only a non because of their bad demand so its probably the one that goes for the lease or 2nd least
4. I value the Cinnabun at a non-1.5 nons also decent overpay
5. A UR aussie alone would proabaly be worth the most of all bids, but a Growing white july, line tribal and all those items?! That would be overpay and their side is worth about 2-2.5 ish nons cuz the growing white july doesnt have the best demand, but still!

If you need a second opinion I agree with watery>~<