The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[myth;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67190457&userid=814854&signature=a4g6BSPdabf2_weGsnyX3A
They/We edited it. How is it now? What else should be added if it still currently isn't fair?

Another 600C$, or a one non dog.

was this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E7rmVQp_gw

Unfair to you, the very rare rat would have been just over enough I do believe.

Hi I'm relatively new and still trying to get a good grasp on fair trading. Is there a guide for trading pets of different years? For example, I'm not really sure what the early 2010 pet on my end here is worth: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WM2vv9_ulg

A 2010 rare is either worth another rare released within 3 months of it's own release, 2 rares from the year after, or 2 uncommons from the year before. So really, the trade you sent wasn't that unfair, if anything you were slightly over.

sorry to be back so soon, but is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -qUS9tYL0Q

Unfair to them, an early 2010 rare is worth 25-30C$, but the zodiacs do have good demand and can easily go for overpay.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67190908&userid=26641&signature=hE-mwwksZvHrrFCs5oB6-w I've just sent this, do you guys think it's fair

Well.. it's unfair to you rarity wise. Your side is worth 3 nons and a bit, there's is worth 1-2 nons depending on how they value the cerb and marionette. The cerb has been trading for 1-2 nons and the marionette a sorbet, and the zebra has been trading for 1-2 nons.. so I think it's fair demand wise? I'd get another opinion.

[beeqlass]

was this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E7rmVQp_gw

Unfair to you, the very rare rat would have been just over enough I do believe.

thank you! could i have second opinions?

[clarke,]

was this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E7rmVQp_gw

Unfair to you, the very rare rat would have been just over enough I do believe.

thank you! could i have second opinions?

I agree with this person's statement. Their side was roughly worth an 09 rare + 010 {maybe}.
Rare rat and one other pet could have traded for their side.

[CheekyRX]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67190908&userid=26641&signature=hE-mwwksZvHrrFCs5oB6-w I've just sent this, do you guys think it's fair

Well.. it's unfair to you rarity wise. Your side is worth 3 nons and a bit, there's is worth 1-2 nons depending on how they value the cerb and marionette. The cerb has been trading for 1-2 nons and the marionette a sorbet, and the zebra has been trading for 1-2 nons.. so I think it's fair demand wise? I'd get another opinion.[/quote]

Thank you, the pets on the other side are more valued to me

[Senbonzakura]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67190733&userid=880548&signature=pHeyQGNQtrbakUtumiplwg

Is this fair?

[watery>~<]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67190908&userid=26641&signature=hE-mwwksZvHrrFCs5oB6-w I've just sent this, do you guys think it's fair

Well.. it's unfair to you rarity wise. Your side is worth 3 nons and a bit, there's is worth 1-2 nons depending on how they value the cerb and marionette. The cerb has been trading for 1-2 nons and the marionette a sorbet, and the zebra has been trading for 1-2 nons.. so I think it's fair demand wise? I'd get another opinion.

I would accept it
Zebras are harder to trade off and their pets are... well.. have better demand
I personally would accept
even if malk dragons do have pretty good demand

[Wayward Sister]

Not sure is this is the best place to ask, but hows the damnd for UR bee right now? Also because the Ur Bee and the sun back are on the same tier, could the be swapped? If not what needs to be added?

[watery>~<]

Not sure is this is the best place to ask, but hows the damnd for UR bee right now? Also because the Ur Bee and the sun back are on the same tier, could the be swapped? If not what needs to be added?

Both the UR Bee and Sunback have great demand
UR Bee goes for around 2-3 nons but
Sunback tends to go for 4-5 nons
so the Sunback has better demand

[clarke,]

Not sure is this is the best place to ask, but hows the damnd for UR bee right now? Also because the Ur Bee and the sun back are on the same tier, could the be swapped? If not what needs to be added?

This should go on the "what is this pet worth"thread.

[holodog]

Item(total 603) + advent list trade
I'm not 100% confident in my judgement of item worth in C$/pets but this is basically just a "rough draft" trade, so what would need to be added to either side to make this fair?