The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Nova-Moshi]

Does anyone think this is fair for warrior cats?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3cbY3U1Q3g

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67005401&userid=682231&signature=RKArYrBnLMHCFJYq3lnKyw
Is this fair? I don't know the demand for this pet they have but I swear it can NOT be worth that of a Nov 2008

Their pet is a store pet so it's worth about a mid 2010 rare. So it's unfair to you by 3 2009 uncommons, or a little under a 2009 rare

[bee ♥]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6RZIJJMd0w
Thanks!

They are overpaying by a lot;;

one of their late 2010 rares = your 2017 store pet
one of their 2016 commons = your 2017 uncommon
four of their 2016 commons= your 2015 uncommon

and the rest of the pets on their side is overpay.

[aylah]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... izgAXOj9Kg


Is this bid for my Non-Tag fair? Let me know asap!! Thanks so much!😊

[Stardust;]

For future reference, was this fair? Thank you in advance!

Edit:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66978450&userid=664905&signature=8NQ7Zgd1gmNpizgAXOj9Kg


Is this bid for my Non-Tag fair? Let me know asap!! Thanks so much!😊

No, it's unfair to you. The Non-Tag is worth 3 Sorbets.

[bee ♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66978450&userid=664905&signature=8NQ7Zgd1gmNpizgAXOj9Kg


Is this bid for my Non-Tag fair? Let me know asap!! Thanks so much!😊

Its unfair to you;; their side is roughly worth a sorbet and a half when your side is worth 3 sorbets.

[c!Dream]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=67005401&userid=682231&signature=RKArYrBnLMHCFJYq3lnKyw
Is this fair? I don't know the demand for this pet they have but I swear it can NOT be worth that of a Nov 2008 even as an RR

no this is very unfair on you! about pet is worth way more. i wouldn't accept it

[kjzq]

which trade is worth more ? (the other person's side)
1 or 2

Trade 1.
Mid 09 rare: 35-40C$
Mid 09 rare: 35-40C$
Early 10 rare: 25-30C$
Early 10 rare: 25-30C$
Mid 10 rare: 20-25C$
Late 10 rare: 15-20C$
Late 10 rare: 15-20C$
12' rare: 7-10C$
12' rare: 7-10C$

Total:Roughly 184-225C$



Trade 2.
08' VR- roughly 50C$
08' VR- roughly 50C$
15 store pet: 30-35C$
15 store pet: 30-35C$
15 rare: 2-4C$
15 rare: 2-4C$
15 rare: 2-4C$
15 rare: 2-3C$
16 rare: 1-3C$
17 store pet: 20-25C$
Items: 2017 CS Bday: about 1C$ each

Total: roughly 193-218C$

The first trade is probably worth more in C$ but I would get another opinion if you're looking for demand (:

thank you, may i have a second opinion ? (also, the horses in trade 2 are tier 4 advents, not just 08 vrs ^^)

[Aphrodisiac]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66981544&userid=775738&signature=mlv6052ep9nPlTsKoZohyw

Is this fair for GrayStripe?

[HorseDad]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JsHkI_bhiQ

I know this is EXTREAMLY unfair to me, but they were open to suggestions. What would a full nick toxic set be worth? Or at least what would a 2009 vr be currently worth? Any help is VERY much appreciated :):)